Pages

Showing posts with label Love. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Love. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Looking at Our Own Reality

How does our own personal sense of reality arise? The answer seems obvious, but a little reflection proves that to be too simple. The obvious answer is that we feel our own bodily sensations—and also that we, ourselves, know this, this “Here I am.” There is a distinct duality present in this simple state of self-awareness. One polarity is a sense of continuity, of persistence. I was awfully worn out yesterday, but now I’m pretty chipper. The knowledge that I was and now I am—and simultaneously aware of both—is that sense of continuity. I remember being tired; my body is now energetic. The knowledge belongs to me; it is still there. And the mere fact of forgetting doesn’t change that. Thus for instance I haven’t the vaguest of how I felt at 9:20 a.m. on July 11, 2009. Indeed 2009, which is just the other day, is a pretty fuzzy memory unless I start consulting calendars to bring some of it back. Nevertheless I feel innately certain that I was present back in that vague past. So here we have it: continuity, persistence, now tired, now chipper, but while these states cycle, something remains unchanged. That something is the consciousness of my persistence.

The other pole of this duality, of course, is change itself. There is me—and the other, the over against. The most obvious “over against” is my body. The other, greater over against has changed over time, in itself and also in relation to me. Once it was Minnesota, then Virginia, then Kansas, then Missouri, then Germany, then Hungary. My body has also changed. Once it was small and young, now it is big and old. It is still the over against because it has changed—but “Here I am” has not.

So much for the obvious. But is that sufficient to make us feel real? One way to test that is to imagine ourselves in a situation where nothing else is present but Here I am and Stuff out there, the body close and intimate, all else a step removed—pleasing when it’s edible or drinkable, dangerous when it is hard and cold. A world like that would very quickly make us feel deep anguish. The closest to a documented case like that is the life of Helen Keller—close but not quite perfect. Keller was 19 months of age when an illness deprived her of sight and hearing. As I’ve noted in this blog earlier, she was beginning to learn to speak, was imitating phrases that she’d heard. She had also learned the word for water and remembered it (as “wah-wah”) throughout her painful period of mental darkness. Until she reached age seven and finally got help, she lived in a state of powerful frustration, longing to communicate somehow by using signs and gestures. It’s not a perfect case because she had, at an early age, already discovered—not the other but the others. Her fabulous story is of the greatest value in vividly showing how vitally important for a personal sense of reality is the presence of, and communication with, other Here I am’s.

Long ago and far away I came across a great truth. I think it was in Franklin Merrell-Wolff’s Pathways Through to Space. It is that the two great paths exist for human development, one based on heightened consciousness (Enlightenment) and the other through relationship (Love). Merrell-Wolff’s path was the first; indeed it seems to rank very high among the mystics. But I’d assert that Love is prior and higher—indeed that in its absolute absence, in a world of mental darkness such as Keller experienced in childhood—the very tools for higher awareness are denied us. Language, the tool we need for the first-mentioned path, comes about because we use it to relate to other living beings just like us. It begins with that wah-wah in earliest childhood. Our personal reality depends intrinsically on relationship—as does genuine transcendence. All else is secondary.

The Buddha ranks highest in the category of Enlightenment—achieved by a great act of denial, as it were. What were the roots of that effort? Seeing human misery when Siddhartha Gautama was young: compassion. And when the Buddha achieved his aim, what did he do? Did he pass on into Nirvana? If he had done so, some farmers would have found a desiccated body under that now famous bodhi tree. But no. The Buddha returned to the world to—to communicate, to relate. And one of the great religions sprouted from that seed. No. There are no genuine solitaries high or low. Enlightenment needs its justifying polarity too. Ultimately transcendence falls apart unless there is another person out there to give this person his or her reality.

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Elusive Word: Love

I’ve been rereading an old Harper Torchbooks edition of Martin Buber’s Eclipse of God, nine lectures Buber gave at universities in 1951. The book appeared a year later and, as I’ve just discovered, is till available from Amazon but now from Humanity Books. The lectures centered on a critique of modern philosophies, most centrally on existentialism (Heidegger, Sartre) and Jungian psychology. These “eclipse” God in the sense of a person—and for Buber, most famed for his writing about the “I and Thou” relationship, always between persons, the eclipse really means turning a personal God into either “the God of the philosophers” (Pascal’s phrase), thus into a transcending idea, or into a human self, namely one’s own, a word that Jung liked to render always with a leading cap. The central essay in this book is titled “The Love of God and the Idea of Deity”—a very revealing lecture in that it attempts give some reality to the nature of the love that humanity can feel for God.

Back in the 1950s—and my scribbled comments are still there in the margin—I had already learned to shake my head at the self-centered and the abstract treatments of the subject. The elevation of the self, individuated or not, into a kind of private deity never agreed with me, seeming to be a kind of cul de sac. At the same time, an abstraction cannot love or be loved. For this reason Deuteronomy 6:5, “And you shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your might” either lacks all meaning in any real human context—or I was missing some hidden meaning in the word love itself.

In Buber’s personalistic thought it is the presence of God, always and everywhere, that is an underlying intuitive foundation of the sort of love Deuteronomy points to—very poorly. Buber says that the actual words in Exodus 3:14, usually translated as “I am that I am” actually are “I shall be there”—therefore presence. “I am with you always,” as in Matthew 28:20. “There is no spot where God is not” is a favorite phrase of ours here—and has the same totally personalistic connotation, intentionality, and aura that the I-Thou relationship holds in Buber’s thought. Those we love are always present to us—no matter how many miles may separate us. This feeling is a matter of experience.

There is a Sufi story about a master who gave each of his disciples a live pigeon and told them to wring its neck somewhere where nobody could see the act. All the disciples, except one, came back with dead pigeons. One came back with the pigeon still alive. Asked why he had failed, the disciple said: “There is no place where God can’t see me.”

Contrast this sort of thing with the usually abstract discussions of God—and gradually the notion of what loving God might actually mean emerges, however faintly. Love is the most elusive of words. Yes, we do know its manifestations at the sensory levels—but it is as we leave that level behind that it becomes oddly translucent so that, eventually, even the love of God becomes gradually accessible. But, Lord, it’s a steep mountain—and the simple commands of Just Do It, and with all your heart and soul and might, is not a ski-lift.

Monday, February 1, 2010

The Puzzle of Attention

Why do people seek attention? It is one thing to recognize the attention needs of people, another to locate its roots.

The easy explanation is that we need others’ attention before we can get something from them or induce them to do something for us. We avoid some people’s attention because we don’t want to have “anything to do” with them. But while all this is undoubtedly true, the explanation is insufficient. In many of our interactions, not least the most intimate, attention, as such, is a value we seek in and of itself. To illustrate:

Suppose I am invited to a party by a pleasant couple I have met. I show up and find a lot of people already present. A stranger receives me at the door, asks my name, leads me into the room full of people, and introduces me to the nearest group. The group opens and includes me. Drinks, snacks are served. I lack nothing, not even pleasant conversation. But I notice that my host and hostess actually receive guests who arrive after I do; they also spend some time fussing over them. But they never even approach me. And at the end, as the party is breaking up, and the hosts are saying their good-byes to everyone, they manage to be diverted just as I approach. I wait for a bit at the door—but they don’t return. Finally, a bit embarrassed, I just leave.

That party will stick in memory as a failure despite the excellent champagne, tasty food, and a dozen people with whom I held interesting conversations. But why am I distraught? Because I failed to get the minimum attention I thought that I’d deserved. The couple had invited me—paid me some attention—then treated me as if I did not exist. The party would have been quite satisfactory had I had, say, forty seconds of actual one-on-one with even one member of that couple.

Odd, isn’t it? The attention I did receive from other guests was not a substitute. The pleasant couple, in retrospect, therefore comes to be negatively tinged in my memories.

Now let’s sharpen this example and suppose that I can always get adequate attention from people with whom I’m only casually linked—store clerks, people in parks, at concerts, in libraries—but never from people I value. Let us say that people I value will interact with me, but only very casually and only ever at my instigation. They’re pleasant, but it’s a formal sort of pleasantry, nothing even approaching intimacy. They might wave casually but never rush up to me, never inquire with any feeling how I am, what I have been doing.

It would be the strangest sort of thing. To write a story about such a person would rapidly build suspense. The reader would want to know the reason why. It would be a kind of shunning. But why is shunning painful if—as in this case—the person would get all that he or she needs to have the usual things that civilization provides—nice car, apartment, ample funds, good health, etc.

Is there some kind of hidden energy inside genuine attention. Is genuine attention something we need in order genuinely to be. Or to be well? Is love, which makes the world go round, the secret ingredient in attention—that which makes us really value it? Is that the case? And could we really continue to live without it—or with the thinned out form of it which casual relations give us?

That something of genuine value is present in attention is embedded in language. We say “pay attention.” A payment is something of value bestowed on someone else. In German the directly translation of that phrase is to “gift attention,” Aufmerksamkeit schenken. In that formulation too, a gift is something of value. To pay attention to something or to someone, therefore, implies giving something of value, something that we possess, to someone or something outside of us. The very fact that we need attention as such—not merely in order to get some external service or material object—testifies to the mysterious quality of attention, to an energy within it, which may be the energy of love. Scattering this energy on all sorts of unworthy objects and distractions would therefore seem to be a negligent sort of expenditure of a hidden treasure.

Monday, November 2, 2009

On Love: Well Worth Reading

Herewith a pointer to what I consider to be a superb, brief post entitled “Aquinas on Amor” on Siris. It is a repost of an entry that first appeared last year. Aquinas had a crystal-clear vision, and here it is summarized with skill and parsimony. Click here to see it.