Pages

Showing posts with label Rabia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rabia. Show all posts

Friday, November 12, 2010

Get In The Habit

One impetus behind this post is a link sent in a comment to a post of mine on Ghulf Genes. The link is to an essay by Alasdair MacIntyre (accessible here) on The Nature of Virtues. The second is a post on Siris yesterday (here) addressing the question Is Faith a Virtue? Sometimes comments on blogs are just not the way to present one’s own response to highly stimulating ideas of enormous complexity, hence I thought I’d sort out my own thoughts on the matter of virtue here.

In one sense virtue and morality are very closely linked—or indeed synonymous. I find this in Webster’s first definition of virtue, rendered as “a conformity to a standard of right: Morality.” In an earlier posting I’ve at least touched on the subject of morality (here) focusing on its ambiguities. Virtue, by contrast, although very slippery (for reasons that follow), turns out to be simple and straightforward.

As MacIntyre shows, the word is rooted in the Latin vir, man, and is therefore manliness—a concept that different times define in different ways. It also carries the meaning of excellence—and when we speak of the virtue of a plant, say in a medical context, it means efficiency or efficacy. By way of example MacIntyre discusses the meaning of virtue in Homer, Aristotle, the New Testament’s so-called theological virtues (faith, hope, and charity), in Jane Austen’s work, and in Benjamin Franklins. The contrasts are quite striking. MacIntyre’s essay is well worth reading just to see how he parses apart two motivations behind virtue, which he labels external and internal. External motivation comes from rewards you hope to gain; internal motivation arises from the inward experience of some practice, e.g., the sheer pleasure of doing a job right. My own view of the external/internal split has been to deny the presence of virtue if the motive is external, to recognize it when it is internal. Rabia al-Adawiyya’s saying always comes to my mind. “If I worship you from fear of hell, condemn me to hell. If I do so in the hope of paradise, deny me paradise.” I’m with her.

So long as we view virtue through the lens of qualities, tendencies, or endowments (like “manly strength” in Homer), the concept remains slippery. Natural endowments lack the immediate sense of a moral quality I tend to associate with the word. It helps me a great deal to define it more sharply from actual experience—always my tendency. And here I get real help from Augustine and Thomas Aquinas. Augustine defined virtue as “a good habit consonant with our nature.” Aquinas calls it “an operative habit essentially good.” Here I footnote the Catholic Encyclopedia (link). As a habit virtue loses its mystery and becomes straight-forward. Habits are acquired by repeatedly doing something—and if a difficulty must be overcome, thus a higher good must be preferred over a lower, it involves an act of the will. Thus virtue becomes, you might say, a record of repeatedly choosing right. Experience teaches that we naturally tend toward the good; the difficulties arise when we become aware of an ascending scale of goods and realize that lower goods often have more immediate and sensory rewards. A realization, thus a conscious mental grasp of these differences must first arise before a choice even faces us. And before virtue, the habit, is present, our naked will must form it by repeating what at first are relatively painful choices.

Now here I underline that a recognition is necessary—a kind of inward knowing. In my experience this is not an intellectual operation. My word for it is intuitive. I know the difference, for me, but I cannot speak for others. I don’t know what Aquinas really meant by intellect; the internal experience of that concept, for him, might have been be quite different from mine; for me it ranks lower than intuition and, therefore, unless the intellectual formulation gets intuition’s nod, I view it with a certain reserve.

Here then arises the issue of faith as a virtue. Faith in a structure of doctrines—which includes faith in the authority on which they rest—absolutely demands an intuitive assent. We are dealing here with matters that cannot be confirmed in the usual ways. Faith has a much closer relationship to truth than to goodness. Once I believe that something is thus and so, must I continuously repeat that affirmation? The reason why faith plays such a gigantic role in Christianity, it seems to me, is because its fundamentally very complex doctrine does not meet with intuitive assent as readily, say, as belief in God. Hence, perhaps, the affirmation must be repeated—because it’s not genuinely believed; in that context it can become a virtue. Further, faith in God does not by any means logically and automatically produce the Christian doctrines unless we first accept a very particular formulation of how God relates to man. But fear of hell or hope for paradise should not compel a person to act against the movements of his heart.

Wednesday, September 23, 2009

Power Tempts

Many who reject religion and wouldn’t be caught dead engaged in “worship” are nonetheless temped by spiritual power. People who lean this way are reassured by naturalistic descriptions of the spiritual. If the spiritual is a higher or occult kind of power, a power we can tap, capture, and deploy to benefit ourselves, why—that sounds like science. Science? I’d call it magic.

But we’re all of us subject to this temptation. As we emerge from matter, we all go through a magical phase. Some of us get stuck there not because we manage to develop genuine powers but because we discover that we can attract attention and even make money by exploiting the mysterious. At one level attention is money. The magical, however named, is a sizeable industry, its products: books, movies, services, training, music, holy objects with special virtues, websites, and many kinds of groups. People pass through these groups like water through a filter; they leave money behind as they pass. They come expecting powers, are disillusioned, and flow on to other fake “attractors.” Guardians of these faux treasures benefit.

Fear is the other side of power. To conquer fear is to gain power. An element of trade, of quid pro quo, adheres to many religions despite the best efforts of individuals within them to combat this ultimately low tendency. The verse from Proverbs (1:7) is instructive as well as subtle: “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom.” This single sentence in a way sums up the essence of transcendental experience. The fear is a beginning point, felt by those who are becoming conscious. What is rarely stressed is the important word in this verse: beginning. Fear is just a stimulus, the lowest form of an emerging knowledge. I note here in passing, as it were, that our success in mastering nature, illusory though it is—and the great improvement in our standard of living—is the best explanation for the decline of organized religion. Fear has been lowered. I call our mastery illusory because it greatly depends on fossil fuels; and those we shall eventually exhaust; then fear may return and, quid pro quo, religion will once more thrive. An early illustration of this? Church attendance surged immediately after 9/11. Has that surge lasted? I wonder…

Serious travelers of the Borderzone eventually discover that such travel is like art: you do it for its own sake. Indeed, if done for any other reason, it isn’t genuine travel, so to say, but just a form of tourism: snap a few photos and gather a subject or two for conversation once you get home. “Why, the last time we were at the Riviera…”

One of the best-known Sufi saints—and virtually none is known in the West—was Rabia al-Adawiyya (717-801 AD). She put this matter succinctly: “If I worship you for fear of hell, condemn me to hell. If I do so in hope of paradise, deny me paradise.” Why do I cite a Sufi saint of Basra, in Persia, rather than, say, one of the many Christian saints, not least St. Teresa of Avila, who voiced many of the same sorts of sentiments? Here is an sample: “More tears are shed over answered prayers than unanswered ones.” I cite a Sufi saint because outer forms wear out. There is a reflexive rejection in the West of our own traditions and experience. But we must remember this: all those who wander the hidden ways are in the same country and hold the same citizenship, but people get confused by the different traditional garb that they wear.

Reality and its phenomena always have a naturalistic aspect—which does not mean that there is no awareness and personality behind them; there always is, as in us. To rely on one side of this coin and neglect the other is to worship power ignorantly. Yes, power is tempting. The paradox is that our actual possession of it manifests when we no longer seek it. At that point we’ve made a few steps past the beginning and the radiance of wisdom begins to manifest like a predawn light under the horizon.

—————

Picture credit: Wikipedia here.