In religious acculturation the most important element is barely touched upon—so that we don’t even recognize the very experience of it when it arises spontaneously. We don’t in any way link it to religion. I find it interesting that the etymology for religion Cicero once offered is right on target—at least for me. He thought the word derived from “again” and “reading”—relegare. When we expand the concept to include pondering on things, as in reflecting upon, we are very close to the idea of contemplation—thus to “reflecting on the higher or the elevated.” Others have preferred deriving the word from religare, meaning to fasten or to bind fast, thus pointing to a bond between the human and divine. But the sense of that word (binding) also holds the notion of an obligation, an obligation laid on us. And, indeed, my own religious acculturation had plenty of that. It was commandment-based. Do this; do not do that. And there are consequences. Thus religion came in the form of behavioral dicta—not at all dissimilar to “Look before you cross the street—or you might be run over,” the main difference being that the “run over” portion of the teaching was projected in time to a vague and misty sort of place. We were even taught to pray under the rubric of obligation—never ever under the rubric of nutrition. Yet prayer is the closest we get to contemplation in these contexts—and the genuine religious life is actually centered on it.
We were children, of course. The acculturation was more social than religious. Religious acculturation ought to be life-long, and should have institutional support to channel the wisdom in more or less formal ways, but this isn’t in the cards. Usually after 10, maximally after 18 years of age, religious education altogether ceases. Not surprisingly the vast majority is far more ignorant of religion than, say, of high school science. Now, to be sure, coming from a family where Montessori education is highly regarded—and entirely ignored by the world—my view of the rest of education, never mind religious, is equally unprintable. Therefore the religious life, when it is actually practiced, especially by a few members of the laity, is the world’s most hidden activity of all.
At least in West—saying which I engage in one of those ploys you’ll find in Games People Play. (To take the air out of some windbag mouthing generalities, wait until he finishes and then say, “Yes, but not in the East.”) Some religious traditions—I’m thinking of Buddhism—place detachment and inward-directed contemplation much more prominently than the avoidance of sin, obedience to doctrine, and ritual practices—or the euphoric acceptance of Christ preferably in a crowd with lots of people shouting hallelujahs. Perhaps in those Eastern reaches more of the acculturation sticks and lasts beyond childhood.
What comes first? Inner awakening—which is fed (literally, actually, tangibly) by contemplative activities—or behavioral conformity? The first is first, I think. If it is not awakened and active in the person, morality of behavior, even after it has become a habit, is much too easily eroded by unhappy circumstances. Inner awakening is like a spring. Once it flows, it is avidly watched—and when the turmoil of life starts to clog up its channel, the motivation to clean it out and help it flow again arises right out of the pain of life.
Concerning nutrition and prayer in the Christian tradition, I suggest this earlier short post.
Showing posts with label Prayer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Prayer. Show all posts
Saturday, July 16, 2011
Friday, May 14, 2010
Concerning Techniques
All of us who become aware of a complex universe—personally, actually aware, not merely repeating learned beliefs without genuine personal effort to understand—then experience the dilemma of a split. The ranges of reality not readily accessible to the senses become real; but our attention is pulled into the world. To detach is difficult, to detach effectively almost impossible. Nor does it always seem appropriate: we have responsibilities, and not merely for those things immediately before us. We are embedded in the society as a whole. We form links in myriad networks. As members of families we have loved ones we care about, and these networks grow enormously as we age. And beyond our families are others, ranging from those who are, for all intents and purposes, powerfully related to us, sometimes closer than relatives. We have friends, neighbors. And although the feelings diminish with distance and numbers, the welfare of humanity as a whole is our concern. We are our brother’s keeper. This makes it problematical to leave the world go hang—even if we had the wealth or dared to live in genuine poverty such that we could entirely look away. We’re in the world, like it or not. And out attachment follows our attention; nor is attention a kind of neutral sort of power; it produces identification. And thus we tend to become the prisoners of our own concerns.
Interesting techniques have come down to us over time, developed by the gifted—or the stubborn. They range from periodic, but daily, detachment and remembering—prayer and meditation. But my experience is that all things repeated decay into habit. Whatever becomes routine loses its force. Therefore it’s good to develop an arsenal of techniques so that when the morning’s meditation begins to lose its power—and an hour after meditating, driving to work, we find ourselves literally or internally shouting obscenities at some driver who’s cut in front of us—then it’s time to pick up something else, wipe it clean, begin to use it again, until its potency is weakened too. Then something else.
One technique I’d heard about—and used—is to split the attention, thus to attempt, at all times, to be aware. This is sometimes rendered as “remembering the self.” This one comes from Sufi sources. A Christian variant is the Jesus Prayer, repeated constantly. It has its counterpart in the Hindu mantra and in the repetition of the names of God in Muslim culture. “Self-remembering” is a secular version of these. This technique is powerful when you first attempt it—but the problem is that you have to remember to remember; and by the time you’ve trained yourself to do so, the technique may have lost its effectiveness. But at times like that there is always something else worth trying.
One time I had the notion that it might be useful to use my own habits as a reminder. Most of us wear watches, and most on the left wrist. But the right side is available. So I switched my watch to the right side. For a while this worked quite nicely. The absence of the watch reminded me. It broke the spell of identification. And that is the value of such techniques—to serve as reminders.
It’s also useful, sometimes, to be reminded—which a blog entry like this can do. Hence it serves a purpose. But victory in this realm—indeed in this dimension—is never due to any kind of technique. If it were, we’d all be walking on water.
And this, then, managed to get me past the furies that this morning’s paper managed to produce in me. But something reminded me—in effect it was Brigitte’s recent teaching me how to tie my shoelaces so that they’ll lie across my shoe, rather than pointing at its tip—reminded me that I mustn’t indulge but get past all that. It’s a big universe, out there, and in the end, all is well.
Interesting techniques have come down to us over time, developed by the gifted—or the stubborn. They range from periodic, but daily, detachment and remembering—prayer and meditation. But my experience is that all things repeated decay into habit. Whatever becomes routine loses its force. Therefore it’s good to develop an arsenal of techniques so that when the morning’s meditation begins to lose its power—and an hour after meditating, driving to work, we find ourselves literally or internally shouting obscenities at some driver who’s cut in front of us—then it’s time to pick up something else, wipe it clean, begin to use it again, until its potency is weakened too. Then something else.
One technique I’d heard about—and used—is to split the attention, thus to attempt, at all times, to be aware. This is sometimes rendered as “remembering the self.” This one comes from Sufi sources. A Christian variant is the Jesus Prayer, repeated constantly. It has its counterpart in the Hindu mantra and in the repetition of the names of God in Muslim culture. “Self-remembering” is a secular version of these. This technique is powerful when you first attempt it—but the problem is that you have to remember to remember; and by the time you’ve trained yourself to do so, the technique may have lost its effectiveness. But at times like that there is always something else worth trying.
One time I had the notion that it might be useful to use my own habits as a reminder. Most of us wear watches, and most on the left wrist. But the right side is available. So I switched my watch to the right side. For a while this worked quite nicely. The absence of the watch reminded me. It broke the spell of identification. And that is the value of such techniques—to serve as reminders.
It’s also useful, sometimes, to be reminded—which a blog entry like this can do. Hence it serves a purpose. But victory in this realm—indeed in this dimension—is never due to any kind of technique. If it were, we’d all be walking on water.
And this, then, managed to get me past the furies that this morning’s paper managed to produce in me. But something reminded me—in effect it was Brigitte’s recent teaching me how to tie my shoelaces so that they’ll lie across my shoe, rather than pointing at its tip—reminded me that I mustn’t indulge but get past all that. It’s a big universe, out there, and in the end, all is well.
Labels:
Mediation,
Prayer,
Techniques
Thursday, February 18, 2010
Supersubstantial?
What follows here is something very arcane, sorry, but it happens to be meaningful to me. First the context. In the last post I suggested that life itself is a transcendent energy, different from chemical energy. We need both. This morning I literally chanced across variant translations, in Latin, of the phrase “Give us this day our daily bread,” Matthew 6:11 and “Give us day by day our daily bred,” Luke 11:3. St. Jerome, who did the translation from Greek into Latin, rendered the first as Panem nostrum quotidianum da nobis hodie (“Give us this day our daily bread”) and the second as Panem nostrum supersubstantialem da nobis hodie (“Give us this day our supersubstantial bread”). In both cases the variant word in Greek is epiousion, derived from epiousios. Epi stands for on, over, above. Ousios means substance, being, essence, nature.
Now the plot thickens. The Greek word is of extreme rarity, what is known as a hapax, thus a word or phrase that occurs only once or a few times in a work, an author, or a language. Evidently epiousios appears only twice in the Greek version of the Bible and nowhere else. All this I gathered from several sites. The subject is generously discussed by Wikipedia in an article on the very subject here. The presumption is that Jesus used an unusual word in Aramaic or Hebrew (see this article by Fr. Benjamin Reese) which the Greek translator strained, as it were, to render into Greek—and which Jerome then rendered as “daily” in Luke and as “supersubstantial” in Matthew.
I think this is quite interesting. I know no Greek, am not a scholar, have not engaged in textual hermeneutics, and, until this morning, knew absolutely nothing about this somewhat controversial issue of translation. I came across this matter quite by chance—as if there is such a thing in such matters. I was checking out the Maverick Philosopher’s blog. His post for February 17, the topmost this morning (here), was titled “Why Run?” and dealt with daily hiking, running, and cycling—the daily bread of legs and lungs. He ends the post with the Latin quote Panem nostrum quotidianum da nobis hodie. It was in running down this phrase, which vaguely echoed in my head from my Catholic childhood, that led to the discovery of that strange epiousios and its possible relevance to my post on February 16 suggesting that some kind of “transcendent” energy keeps us “alive”—while food nourishes our bodies.
Now the plot thickens. The Greek word is of extreme rarity, what is known as a hapax, thus a word or phrase that occurs only once or a few times in a work, an author, or a language. Evidently epiousios appears only twice in the Greek version of the Bible and nowhere else. All this I gathered from several sites. The subject is generously discussed by Wikipedia in an article on the very subject here. The presumption is that Jesus used an unusual word in Aramaic or Hebrew (see this article by Fr. Benjamin Reese) which the Greek translator strained, as it were, to render into Greek—and which Jerome then rendered as “daily” in Luke and as “supersubstantial” in Matthew.
I think this is quite interesting. I know no Greek, am not a scholar, have not engaged in textual hermeneutics, and, until this morning, knew absolutely nothing about this somewhat controversial issue of translation. I came across this matter quite by chance—as if there is such a thing in such matters. I was checking out the Maverick Philosopher’s blog. His post for February 17, the topmost this morning (here), was titled “Why Run?” and dealt with daily hiking, running, and cycling—the daily bread of legs and lungs. He ends the post with the Latin quote Panem nostrum quotidianum da nobis hodie. It was in running down this phrase, which vaguely echoed in my head from my Catholic childhood, that led to the discovery of that strange epiousios and its possible relevance to my post on February 16 suggesting that some kind of “transcendent” energy keeps us “alive”—while food nourishes our bodies.
Labels:
Energies,
Jerome,
Lord's Prayer,
Prayer,
Spritiual Life
Saturday, January 16, 2010
The Wider Context of Prayer
The poem by Rumi presented in the last post holds the mystic’s view of reality in a grand context, not least cosmological: “For to-night the teeming world gives birth to the world everlasting.” It presents an upward-trending vector—from dust to spirit and on beyond—call it evolutionary, if you like. Rumi suggests that we are slumbering, asleep—and that this sleep is due to the nature of this dimension (“A heavy slumber fell upon thee from the circling spheres.”) To set out on the quest right here and now, we must awaken and stay watchful. And that, I propose, is the wider context of prayer. We find the same linkage in the New Testament: “Be always on the watch, and pray that you may be able to escape all that is about to happen, and that you may be able to stand before the Son of Man” (Luke 21:36); and “Watch and pray so that you will not fall into temptation” (Matthew 26:41). In these contexts prayer is not petition but something else—attention directed at something. But at what? Not the sensory environment but something beyond it. It is presented as a technique—in Matthew emphasizing the resistance (temptation, the weakness of the flesh) in Luke and in Rumi (“O soul, seek the Beloved, O friend, seek the Friend” “the Son of Man”) pointing to the goal.
Brought into the humdrum world of immediate experience, these teachings suggest that participation in the cosmic process laid down by the Creator involves an effort of attention to a reality that is not immediately perceived. Prayer, which is initially triggered in us by very ordinary if sharply felt needs, may with practice become a watchful consciousness, a contemplation of a range of reality we may only at first access by means of symbols. The practice of watchfulness, however, will persuade the determined person that the attention directed in one direction is also answered from there—but as with all experiential matters, you have to taste it before you know it.
Rumi speaks of this experience as we reach the end of the poem. “Mine eye,” he says, “is from that source and from another universe; here a world and there a world: I am seated on the threshold.” I like that word, threshold. In this blog I call it the borderzone.
Brought into the humdrum world of immediate experience, these teachings suggest that participation in the cosmic process laid down by the Creator involves an effort of attention to a reality that is not immediately perceived. Prayer, which is initially triggered in us by very ordinary if sharply felt needs, may with practice become a watchful consciousness, a contemplation of a range of reality we may only at first access by means of symbols. The practice of watchfulness, however, will persuade the determined person that the attention directed in one direction is also answered from there—but as with all experiential matters, you have to taste it before you know it.
Rumi speaks of this experience as we reach the end of the poem. “Mine eye,” he says, “is from that source and from another universe; here a world and there a world: I am seated on the threshold.” I like that word, threshold. In this blog I call it the borderzone.
Labels:
Prayer,
Rumi,
Scriptures
Thursday, January 14, 2010
Prayer and Worship
We engage in spontaneous prayer when we call to God in our distress—or when, in moments of sudden gladness or relief, we thank God without any thought or reservation in an overflow of gratitude.
It seems to me that worship belongs in another category. Our closest experience of worship is to fall in love—and the younger we are, the closest the approximation. Young love is still unaware of sexuality and the feeling is therefore pure. We adore the other in a mute and astonished state of veneration. If in our coarse adulthood we would become even vaguely aware of the Sublime, we would all sink to our knees in helpless worship—our freedom of will suspended. We get closer to this state, worship, when some aspect of the divine actually touches us—channeled, you might say, by some great work of art, usually music. But here as in all things a certain adequacy must be present.
Worship in the usual sense is a kind of mimesis of something we believe in but don’t actually feel—except on extraordinarily rare occasions, briefly. Great music, fine arts, colorful ceremonies, inspiring words: all these are harnessed to make our worship meaningful. But our worship is nevertheless—no matter how emotional—an imitation, an acting out. Worship is something above the emotions. I’m fairly sure that we are actually shielded from the great fire of the divine. If we saw it without any veiling, we would be consumed. What we do see is the veiling. Therefore it is right and proper to behold God behind the beautiful, the majestic, the glorious, and the sublime—when phenomena that support these words appear. They are reflections of something transcending mere mountains, oceans, spring meadows, newborn infants, vast clouds in the blue sky, sunsets, and subtle dawns.
If worship isn’t anchored in our inner core, it’s only a social drill. But I approve of social drill. I see ourselves, society, culture, in fact the whole cosmos as manifesting ascending layers. Social drill is an appropriate activity at a certain level. It reminds us, habituates us, it molds our behavior—and experience teaches. Formal worship tills the soil, you might say, so that something in that soil might sprout. Worship at the high level will come spontaneously—and will not be felt as an obligation in the least—when our inner being has gained the power to behold.
Prayer is closer to us. It springs up from personal need or the release of tension in gratitude. It is an almost instinctive reaching out to an impossible—because invisible—agency for help. We can label this motion of the self as an illusion or, alternatively, ponder whether, perhaps, it is a dim but innate knowledge that our current state is incomplete. Reduced to pure concept, prayer is an acknowledgement of a dimension higher and beyond ours. In prayer we attend to it. We think of attention as “looking at, listening to,” but I’ve come to think of it as a much more potent power, one that transcends the physical (eyes, ears). Here is an instance of the subtle power of attention on this side of the divide: Sometimes when we watch someone intently from behind, someone at quite some distance from us, that person may turn and looks at us. The distance may be quite extensive. Our attention, especially when it is intense (“fervent prayer”) may really open a channel by means of which grace flows our way. In this context the last three quotes of yesterday’s post are relevant. Each emphasizes our state—and what it must be to have our prayer answered.
Someone might object to my take here by saying that I’m playing with fields of energy (“channel opens,” “grace flows”—pure pantheism). They would insist that God is a person, not some electromagnetic field writ large. I agree, actually. The last thing I want to do is to reduce the high to the low. But those who picture God as Mom or Dad writ large are engaged in the same process of reduction. I have no idea how to picture God. What I do know is that in my prayers, I do address a person. But my own experience also bears out that “fervent” or “heartfelt” prayer has a certain quality—and one’s experience of some kind of response depends on this intensity, an intensity I don’t think can be faked. Alternatively, prayer may be deep, but on that subject in a future post. In either case, the model that occurs to me is that we face a shielding which our act of prayer penetrates, be it by intensity or deep inner silence. It is a genuine contact. I also think that all such prayers are always answered—although we may lack the capacity to understand the answer. It may simply be a very slight improvement of our powers of understanding; it may be the removal of one tiny grain of our thick stupidity. Prayer isn’t magic. If it were, the world would be on its knees day and night.
It seems to me that worship belongs in another category. Our closest experience of worship is to fall in love—and the younger we are, the closest the approximation. Young love is still unaware of sexuality and the feeling is therefore pure. We adore the other in a mute and astonished state of veneration. If in our coarse adulthood we would become even vaguely aware of the Sublime, we would all sink to our knees in helpless worship—our freedom of will suspended. We get closer to this state, worship, when some aspect of the divine actually touches us—channeled, you might say, by some great work of art, usually music. But here as in all things a certain adequacy must be present.
Worship in the usual sense is a kind of mimesis of something we believe in but don’t actually feel—except on extraordinarily rare occasions, briefly. Great music, fine arts, colorful ceremonies, inspiring words: all these are harnessed to make our worship meaningful. But our worship is nevertheless—no matter how emotional—an imitation, an acting out. Worship is something above the emotions. I’m fairly sure that we are actually shielded from the great fire of the divine. If we saw it without any veiling, we would be consumed. What we do see is the veiling. Therefore it is right and proper to behold God behind the beautiful, the majestic, the glorious, and the sublime—when phenomena that support these words appear. They are reflections of something transcending mere mountains, oceans, spring meadows, newborn infants, vast clouds in the blue sky, sunsets, and subtle dawns.
If worship isn’t anchored in our inner core, it’s only a social drill. But I approve of social drill. I see ourselves, society, culture, in fact the whole cosmos as manifesting ascending layers. Social drill is an appropriate activity at a certain level. It reminds us, habituates us, it molds our behavior—and experience teaches. Formal worship tills the soil, you might say, so that something in that soil might sprout. Worship at the high level will come spontaneously—and will not be felt as an obligation in the least—when our inner being has gained the power to behold.
Prayer is closer to us. It springs up from personal need or the release of tension in gratitude. It is an almost instinctive reaching out to an impossible—because invisible—agency for help. We can label this motion of the self as an illusion or, alternatively, ponder whether, perhaps, it is a dim but innate knowledge that our current state is incomplete. Reduced to pure concept, prayer is an acknowledgement of a dimension higher and beyond ours. In prayer we attend to it. We think of attention as “looking at, listening to,” but I’ve come to think of it as a much more potent power, one that transcends the physical (eyes, ears). Here is an instance of the subtle power of attention on this side of the divide: Sometimes when we watch someone intently from behind, someone at quite some distance from us, that person may turn and looks at us. The distance may be quite extensive. Our attention, especially when it is intense (“fervent prayer”) may really open a channel by means of which grace flows our way. In this context the last three quotes of yesterday’s post are relevant. Each emphasizes our state—and what it must be to have our prayer answered.
Someone might object to my take here by saying that I’m playing with fields of energy (“channel opens,” “grace flows”—pure pantheism). They would insist that God is a person, not some electromagnetic field writ large. I agree, actually. The last thing I want to do is to reduce the high to the low. But those who picture God as Mom or Dad writ large are engaged in the same process of reduction. I have no idea how to picture God. What I do know is that in my prayers, I do address a person. But my own experience also bears out that “fervent” or “heartfelt” prayer has a certain quality—and one’s experience of some kind of response depends on this intensity, an intensity I don’t think can be faked. Alternatively, prayer may be deep, but on that subject in a future post. In either case, the model that occurs to me is that we face a shielding which our act of prayer penetrates, be it by intensity or deep inner silence. It is a genuine contact. I also think that all such prayers are always answered—although we may lack the capacity to understand the answer. It may simply be a very slight improvement of our powers of understanding; it may be the removal of one tiny grain of our thick stupidity. Prayer isn’t magic. If it were, the world would be on its knees day and night.
Wednesday, January 13, 2010
Prayer
Whatever a man prays for, he prays for a miracle. Every prayer reduces itself to this: “Great God, grant that twice two be not four.” [Ivan Sergeyevich Turgenev, Prayer]
Prayer is the soul’s sincere desire,
Uttered or unexpressed;
The motion of a hidden fire
That trembles in the breast.
[James Montgomery, What is Prayer?]
Prayer from a heart in grace; for who sets store
By other kinds, which are not heard above?
[Dante, Purgatory, Canto IV:134]
It is not a carol of joy or glee,
But a prayer that he sends from his heart’s deep core…
I know why the caged bird sings!
[Paul Laurence Dunbar, Sympathy]
The effectual fervent prayer of a righteous man availeth much. [The General Epistle of James, 5:16]
Prayer is the soul’s sincere desire,
Uttered or unexpressed;
The motion of a hidden fire
That trembles in the breast.
[James Montgomery, What is Prayer?]
Prayer from a heart in grace; for who sets store
By other kinds, which are not heard above?
[Dante, Purgatory, Canto IV:134]
It is not a carol of joy or glee,
But a prayer that he sends from his heart’s deep core…
I know why the caged bird sings!
[Paul Laurence Dunbar, Sympathy]
The effectual fervent prayer of a righteous man availeth much. [The General Epistle of James, 5:16]
Labels:
Prayer
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)