Pages

Friday, April 16, 2010

Dream Puzzle Revisited

My fascination with dreams never ends, but it has a wave-like pattern. The subject fades from view for a while until some dream snippet reminds me of the mystery again. One such snipped came this morning. Nothing dramatic is about to be unfolded. In the dream I was simply sitting on a concrete ledge idly playing with little balls made of soot or ashes, playing in a kind of mindless way. In the dream the very mindlessness of that activity surfaced into awareness; but with awareness suddenly present, I promptly woke up. Ninety times out of a hundred this sort of thing fades by the time I’m halfway down the stairs. Today it was still there—they were still there, those little balls of soot. Sometimes I just stand in the still dark kitchen waiting for the water to boil, the only light coming from above the stove; I’m in what is technically known as a “brown study.” (Where did that phrase originate?) And sometimes then I break that state and force the mind to concentrate.

Doing that this morning, and pondering that snipped with a stern frown on my face, it occurred to me that dreams produce splendid samples of consciousness without self-consciousness. What actually happens, I propose, is this:

As it is gradually aroused from deep and entirely unconscious sleep, the sleeping brain begins to process memories. The memories processed tend to be those of recent experiences—quite frequently thoughts of the night before. In this process the brain arranges what it finds lying about into the best possible patterns—almost as if it were trying to orient itself. The brain lacks visual inputs at this moment; the eyes are closed. Consequently it arranges whatever happens to be present into visual images. This arranging is, of course, a sequential process. And that sequence, that movement in time, is presented as a dynamism, as the “action,” of the dream. Whatever materials the brain thus arranges—remembered objects, actions, or thoughts—were accompanied by a mix of feelings when they happened in reality. The brain also integrates those feelings into the dream pattern. And those feelings then become the consciousness of the dream self.

Now the dream itself, of course, is stored in memory too. And when the self actually returns, when we wake up genuinely, we also become aware of that dream. And then it seems to us as a sequence of lived experience. When we tell the dream, we describe ourselves doing this, doing that, going here, driving a car, etc. — indeed much as above I described myself playing with balls of soot.

But what we do not notice in recalling dreams is the absence of self-consciousness in dreams. Or that, if self-consciousness is present, it is almost immediately followed by awakening.

Today’s dream snippet was as instructive as it was precisely because my brain wove a ridiculous picture. I don’t usually sit around for extended periods playing with marbles—much less marbles made of soot. The real self—wherever it might be during sleep—glimpsed this picture. Its incompatibility with my normal state of mind—and actions—aroused it. But when it becomes a presence, then dreams depart.

The real puzzle of dreams, I think, is focused right there. The puzzle is the absence of the self. Materialism has a very simple explanation—which fits the facts very nicely. There isn’t such a thing. The self is simply the top-most layer of the brain. During dreams it’s still inactive; the dream comes from the lower, the more primitive stem. That region can, if not with great precision, detect anomalies in experience—and when it does, it rouses the higher functions so that they can deal with the “emergency.” My cerebellum was thus smart enough to see that playing with soot-balls was not appropriate behavior; therefore it called the frontal lobe to report this misbehavior—and I promptly awoke.

What you see is what you get. All this makes pretty good sense. But I also see something else—experience something else. It is that the waking self is something quite distinctly and sharply different from any other physical experience I have. Consciousness has a unique quality that I simply cannot with any genuine conviction reduce to the same phenomenological basics as being hungry, thirsty, sleepy, sexy, scared, eager, hot, or cold. I’m also intellectually persuaded that all that I experience must in some way be capable of rational integration—thus that consciousness and meaning must have their own adequate explanation—much as biological or inorganic mechanisms do. Therefore the puzzle for me is where the self is when I dream or sleep. Monistic approaches (e.g., body and soul are sides of the same coin) don’t produce in me, as in so many others, a feeling of closure at all. Concerning where we might go in sleep, that subject I've at least tentatively explored here.

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

The Borderzone Within

There is a borderzone right inside us too—as there is one out there in the macrocosm—but we don’t think of it in mumbo-jumbo or in mystical terms because it is a matter of direct experience. Humanity has treated this matter in countless ways, but it is summed up by that all-too-familiar phrase, body and soul. If we use that duality as the whole, then the “borderzone” in question is really the point where body and soul meet and interact. But that interaction is so puzzling and mysterious, that we’ve dismissed it altogether, conceived of it as a point, have ignored it, have formed all kinds of fantastic theories about it, and have often simply thrown up our hands.

The modern way is to deny it. There is no soul. Enough already. We’re strictly chemistry arranged in a certain dynamic pattern—and that pattern has a kind of tenacious tendency to maintain itself, like a whirlpool does—but no more mysteriously than a whirlpool does; we call that tenacity survival. End of story.

Aristotle proposed that everything has body and soul if only we call the one matter and the other form. The combination of the two is the only real thing. He called it substance, and to this day, if we mean that something’s real, we say that it’s substantial. A consequence of this, of course, is that after our bodies fall apart, what we call “we” disappears. But Aristotle was not quite sure that intellect disappeared; he cut himself some slack, as it were. Almost to a man—and it usually is a man—our deep thinkers imagine the “high” element within us as intellectual. My explanation is that they expend most of their lives in thought; they get to know that faculty genuinely well; but, perhaps, they fail to experience other facets of their beings equally as fully—or observe them with the same care. There are other ways of being—there are other paths: action, art, and love come to mind. Thomas Aquinas, among the greatest thinkers of the medieval era, had a mystical experience shortly before he died. He stopped writing abruptly. Asked why, he answered that all that he had written until then (and it was a monumental opus, still avidly studied today) was “mere straw.” (1) I’ve always valued Aquinas’ thought—but I have valued this story as its crown. Paradoxically, perhaps, it holds a practical as well as a deeper truth.

Descartes, who, in a way, gave modern philosophical thought its original shape, carried simplification to a great height. He proposed two realities, the extended thing (call that the body) and the thinking thing (call that the soul). They were radically different; they communicated and met at one point in the body, in the pineal gland. No, this is not a tongue-in-cheek dismissal; but to get into the complexities of Descartes’ thought on the subject you have to look elsewhere (2). My point is that humanity has struggled with this subject. The borderzone within is a very mysterious aspect of reality—and this despite the fact that it is, for us, the most familiar.

It is our inability to pinpoint precisely where higher and lower meet, to describe in mechanical (or even electromechanical) terms how spirit moves matter, our inability to capture and hold the spirit that has led to the materialistic theories of life. But modern thought had its ancient analogues too—and functionally quite similar. Lucretius was one of these theorists: everything is atoms, he said. They move deterministically, but at unpredictable times they suddenly “swerve.” This accounts for what we would call mental events and the illusion of volition. But atoms that form into bodies by law and swerves, dissolve back into free atoms, ranging from coarse to superfine. All is a dance of occasionally swerving atoms. (3) Modern theories of physics are now approaching the Lucretian level. Statistical explanations of everything real are beginning to eat away even at the claim that laws of nature exist (which, of course, suggests a law-giver) to make everything a product of chance. This is what I call throwing up the hands.

I’m of a mind to see value in all of these approaches. All of them produce raw materials, all of them spin twine useful for making a meaningful cosmology—or an understanding of the self. What we need is the right loom to weave it into fabric. (4) That loom is projected, I think, by emanationist conceptions of reality. I’ve discussed these recently under the heading of “Angels: Heavenly Schematics.” There I have suggested that reality is indeed a creation of two distinct fundamentals; they interact at every level and dynamically—thus either rising toward complexity or moving away from it. Within this dynamic spiral are regions of relative equilibrium. Borderzones are spatially conceived areas where a transition is taking place— from one region to the other. They are spatially conceived because, for us, living where we live, space is a decent concept for locating activity. But let me put this projection into more visual or linear terms.

God created two kinds of realities. One of these are agents, that which we call “we”: persons; selves. The other is what we call matter—but this matter may manifest in a vast range of subtlety—thus more than just what we call matter. We live our lives in a borderzone. What do I mean by that? I mean that both a higher and subtler and a lower and coarser kind are both present in it, mixed, as it were. We are keenly aware of the lower. And, being lower, it has a greater grip on us; why that is so I’ll try to explain in a moment. But we’re also aware of the higher. It charms and draws us. The matter of that world, however is more subtle. It is invisible to us because we are still more aware of the lower region than the higher. The higher is an imaginal (but not an imaginary) world. We sometimes dismissively label it “mental,” signaling that such worlds are unreal. Yet mental creations and realities are very real for us: great myths, great music, great works of art, great structures of thought, grand tales, personal and collective memories. And also personifications like the United States of America or the Red Menace. Lady Macbeth, meet Don Quixote. There’s also our honor—produce it for me to touch if you can—and our shame. With only the slightest of careful observation, we can easily discover that most of the things that really move us, in our daily lives, are structures of the insubstantial kind—impossible to touch although, of course, they have tangible manifestations as print on paper, images on screens, or the bodies of people whose intangible attitudes, thoughts, intentions, benevolence (or lack thereof) are the source of our pleasures and our pains. The lower order, the material aspect, sometimes touches us most irritatingly too. And their disarray, as in Haiti these days, is a great source of pain.

We live our lives in tension here because we’ve entered a developmental region, a borderzone. We come from the lower and are headed upward. But because the lower is more familiar to us, has long been our home, it has more claim on us. Hence we are more aware of it. But, at the same time, we hear the call (but cannot see) a higher region. We interact with both. But after we are freed of bodies, which way shall we go? That is the question. If in some greater scheme we are on a vector, we are lucky to be in a borderzone; we’re also at risk. If we don’t develop, we won’t be able to resist the downward pull of the lower region after death; to be sure, it is the one we already inhabit now. But if we do manage to acquire new powers sufficient to continue in the higher direction, then, at the end of life, awakening to that ability, and finally seeing the higher dimension directly, without the interference of this level’s coarser materiality, we shall look back on all our works, and like Thomas Aquinas, declare them all as “mere straw.”

Thursday, April 8, 2010

The Low and the High

Perhaps the most important concept in sorting out the problems and opportunities of life is that of hierarchy—but the word is repugnant to many. It suggests authority or dominance. Images of ranks appear, prelates in robes and pointed hats, generals bristling with stars and decorations. And the word itself is ambiguous. It comes from two Greek roots of which one is “sacred” (hieros), the other is “ruler” (archon)—so the meaning of holiness is present in it but deformed by the concept of compulsion—because a ruler never stops at leading by example but will have masses of cops and soldiers to carry out his will, whether we like it or not. Thus hierarchy is all tangled up with one level of experience for most—the social. Once it was more closely associated with social mind control, thus with religious ideology. In a secular era the word itself has been secularized to mean any kind of authority. A non-starter for people.

In my personal lexicon the word has lost these connotations long ago. I tend to use the word simply to mean “a structure of values”—and more precisely the notion that all experience manifests itself in layers, from coarse to fine, from gross to subtle, for simple to the complex. And this layered arrangement behaves, in actuality, in a fashion which is precisely the opposite of a human, social, power structure.

What I mean by this is that the highest of values are the least compelling and the lowest the most authoritarian. We disobey our body’s demands at our peril—and often obey involuntarily—whereas we follow our highest callings only ever voluntarily. Similarly, in ordinary experience, the lowest has the most noticeable positive and negative feedback; the highest demands a high level of cultivation even to perceive—and ignoring it carries no sanctions whatsoever—beyond leaving us at a lower level where we’re evidently quite content to be—just keep the beer coming.

I myself think that this arrangement works with the same lawful force as gravity’s. One of its consequences is that no one goes to heaven unless he or she chooses; no one is sent to hell; he or she prefers it. At the same time—and here a subtle distinction also appears—souls may want to go to heaven, but when they arrive, they don’t like it there.

Compulsion rules the world, but freedom rules the spirit. Religion represents a transitional ground. When compulsion is present in it to any degree, it is still merely a social phenomenon no matter what concepts it deploys in its persuasion. When it begins attracting the individual soul by its subtle force and more or less veiled message, it becomes a personal quest and the mechanics of the religion itself will become less and less relevant and, indeed, unimportant. Separating the social compulsion in religion from its inner life is the most difficult task of all—the more so because those who succeed in doing so will be, without fail, expelled from the reservation. But if they are genuinely qualified, they won’t mind this in the least. Threats and seductions will repel the adequate—but may shape and purify those as yet stuck in the world of compulsion. And therein lies the positive work of religion.

The secret also hides itself effectively. What I say here will resonate with some, will cause others to feel opposition—as if I were attacking something holy. The holy is beyond attack. It also can’t be bought and sold.

The principles I have just sketched also work with the same precision in every corner, including the most hidden, of ordinary life as well. There too the coarse will only beget the coarse, force will only ever generate a counterforce, and only dedication will produce rewards that those on a lower level won’t even envy—because they can’t perceive them.

Monday, April 5, 2010

On Awe

Readers of this blog who find it obscure and difficult should turn to the Zohar, the Sefer ha-Zohar, to give it its full name, The Book of Radiance, one of the great books of the Kabbalah. Now there is something really difficult. Thanks to my wife’s thoughtful generosity, I have one volume of this work masterfully translated by Daniel C. Matt, himself a Master, indeed the foremost master in our language on these wonders. Here is a sampling—in which I omit at least as much text in annotations and commentaries as I produce for view—and in this strange world commentaries, and commentaries on commentaries, and so on, layered ad infinitum, are very much part of the tradition:

     Rabbi Shim’on opened with the commandments of Torah, saying, “The commandments of Torah given by the Blessed Holy One to Israel are all written in Torah in general terms.
     “In the beginning God created (Genesis 1:1). This is the first commandment of all, called awe of YHVH, which is called beginning, as is written: The beginning of wisdom is awe of YHVH (Psalms 111:10), Awe of YHVH is the beginning of knowledge (Proverbs 1:7). For this entity is named beginning; it is the gate through which one enters faith. The entire world is based upon this commandment.
     “Awe branches in three directions, two of which are not fittingly rooted, one of which is essence of awe. There is the person who fears the blessed Holy One so that his children may live and not die, or who fears physical or material punishment. Because of this he fears Him constantly, but his awe is not focused on the blessed Holy One.
     “Then there is the person who fears the blessed Holy One because he is afraid of punishment of the other world and the punishment of Hell. Neither of these is the essential root of awe.
     “The essence of awe is that a person be in awe of his Lord because He is immense and sovereign—essence and root of all worlds—before whom everything is considered as nothing, as is said: All the inhabitants of the earth are considered as nothing (Daniel 4:32). One should direct his desire to the site called Awe.”


The “site called Awe,” Daniel C. Matte’s footnote tells us, is Shekinah, the focus of genuine devotion, the tenth Sephirah or emanation of the Kabbalah, a feminine word meaning the Divine Presence, alternatively rendered as the masculine Malkut, The Kingdom.

Saturday, April 3, 2010

Angels: Heavenly Schematics

I am still circling the subject of angels but now would like to enlarged upon the concepts I first outlined in the last post on this subject (“Angels: A Short Overview”). There I proposed two sharply distinct views of angels. We could call these Western and Eastern. The Western view represents a highly-developed cluster of philosophical conceptions; the Eastern provides a very sophisticated image but much less developed in philosophical terminology—perhaps of necessity; the Eastern is much more dynamically complex.

The western view is dominated by the concept of Creation. In that conception God creates a universe. It has a hierarchical structure. Seen from above God is the summit, the angels are a lower order; they are creatures of pure spirit. Beneath that level are humans, composed of spirit and of matter—indeed these two components are considered permanently fused by God’s choice so that the strictly human must always be both. Hence, after the Judgment at the End of Time, we shall have resurrection bodies. Beneath that level come animals, plants, and non-living matter. We can also see this hierarchy from below. To do so we can turn to the poetic formulations of Genesis. There matter is made first; heaven and earth are created, the darkness illuminated. God next makes lower forms, finally man. Angels are missing in this view, but the presumption might be that the creation of “heaven” also includes the creation of angels. The angels then later appear as messengers of God. Here, of course, I’m tracing the Aristotelian, Thomistic formulations in which the two fundamental realities are unformed prime matter and immaterial form.

While the hierarchy is pleasing, the cosmology altogether lacks any kind of justification for matter, as such, except as the wax in which lower orders (not the higher) may be made visible by the impress of form. Matter-form duality admirably fits Aristotle’s concept of substance, but Aquinas has problems maintaining a rationally pleasing hierarchy as he moves on up to the angelic level. If substance is matter-form (hylomorphic), are angels then insubstantial? To get around this problem, Aquinas introduces the notion that angels are also marked by a dual composition; their essence is “substantiated,” as it were, by existence. Aquinas separates essence from existence. God, finally, in Aquinas’ view, is a Being whose essence and existence are one and the same. All I can do here is confess to the opacity of my own intellect. My intuition will not follow me into this thicket. Nothing resonates.

An emanationist schematic of reality pleases me much more—although it has its own challenges. To express that model in static terms—just to make it visible—we might say that reality manifests in degrees of subtlety, from the most gross to the most subtle. But at every level a duality exits—call it matter-form, passive-active, receptive-creative, body-soul, what have you. We might picture each being, substance, or entity as a temporary fusion of two distinct aspects of reality that, in the Ultimate, are one. These two core realities cohere less and less as we descend (or move away) from the Source (God) and appear more and more complexly fused as we ascend to (move toward) the Ultimate. Within the Ultimate the duality disappears into Pure Act. At the other extreme the duality also fuses, but in the sense of “locking up,” thus losing actuality and becoming, at the extreme, the closest imaginable something to non-existence. Here images of Satan, as depicted by Dante in the deepest pit of hell, produce an interesting picture to contemplate.

Still holding the static view, in this schematic angels may be seen as higher entities, thus more complex and unified beings. Humans as simpler and more fragmented entities—but on a much higher level than animals or inorganic matter. But everywhere, at every level, the dualism holds. At every point, from tiniest to greatest, there are analogues to body and to soul. Thus even the minutest subatomic particles of matter have a “pilot wave,” to cite Louis de Broglie and the elaboration of his notion by David Bohm. As above, so below.

The emanationist schematic, which is more akin to the Eastern philosophical traditions, is, however, a dynamic system. That is where, viewed from a Western perspective, problems appear. What we call creation is, in this view, a continuous outflow of divine substance. It “descends” in a way. It becomes ever more coarse as its “distance” from God increases. The problem? The problem is that spatial concepts are required to understand this model. But so does, of course, the Western notion of creation, but we are just more used to that one and rarely bother wondering if God first had to create a “space” for his creation. The Kabbalists (Isaac Luria, for instance) did actually wonder—and proposed that God’s first act was to create a vacuum. The scheme also appears to be a species of pantheism—but that need not be so. We need only make two assumptions to redeem it. One is that this outflow is a circulation. The other is that, on it ascent back to the One, the creation has achieved a higher degree of perfection. A third assumption might be that the creation itself, in the persons of the souls God has created at the outset of the downward flow, participate in the creation by using their free will—or don’t. This freedom, of course, only resides in one of the two core “elements” that make up creation, not in the other. That one is what we call soul, the entity. The other, by contrast, always follows strict laws—which even the free soul cannot suspend. Thus what we call a miracle consists of the lifting of matter from a lower to a higher level, not the violation or suspension of God’s law at all.

In this dynamic model, beings are perpetually descending and ascending, some outward bound to learn or to experience limitation, some inward bound to realize a higher form. Both the down and upward trajectories are spiraling structures—away from unity and back toward it. In this view separate creation of angelic orders, of humans, of animals, of plants becomes unnecessary—which would please Occam. The creation begins to take on a vastly more elegant form. And, pleasingly, what we see through the narrow lens of science appears in harmonious concordance with what our intuitions of the great whole whisper to us in the silence.

Thursday, April 1, 2010

Distraction

Several people in my circle have recently expressed intentions to rid themselves of stuff, to find again the source of inspiration, to simplify their lives, to get back to the basics, to minimize distractions. Hearing this, images rise in my head. One is that of swimming against a powerful current in a raging torrent. That, you might say, is a good image of life. We are engaged in a passage, and it is difficult. We don’t want to be encumbered. We don’t want our strokes to be impeded by heavy clothing, clunky shoes. We don’t want to carry stuff that turns our arms and legs to lead. We don’t want a vestibule filled with soaked clothing strapped to our back. Swimming against this current, we want to see strong branches where we can pause, firm places where we can rest. We want to reach that blessed yonder shore and not be swept away, away, away.

Our view of reality might be inverted. This came to mind the other day when I saw a poem quoted on Siris (here) by Christina Rossetti. It has two stanzas. One begins with “Man’s life is death.” The other with “Man’s death is life.” The context is Christ’s redemptive work—which is, of course, centrally relevant. Every religious and spiritual system counsels a kind of minimalism. We must do what we must do—but we must never do more than we must. The urge to simplify, the call of the Silence (wherein the still small voice is heard), that is the real call of Life. The vast turbulence of modern life—but ancient life was not really different—is the sound of fragmentation, the raw gravitational pull of the lower dimensions of darkness—however loud they shout, however bright they glitter.

Me, too, as it were. I too intend it more than I manage to do it. There is an old Jewish phrase: “The master of return.” The master or mistress of return is the person who, endlessly failing in the chosen task nevertheless, after each failure, returns to the effort once again. Not the last time that we make strong resolutions to clean up our act. We’re journeying through the valley of the shadow of death; we long for still waters and green pastures. Even in the midst of this turbulence of endless…distraction.

Monday, March 29, 2010

Fascinating Parallels

Those who read very obscure books and have the stomach for extraordinarily outlandish ideas—such people sometimes stumble across fascinating parallels.

To maintain, for instance, that there are choirs of angels that concern themselves exclusively with kidney functions most people would dismiss as beyond—and I mean way beyond—the pale. Yet Emanuel Swedenborg offers this idea in all seriousness not only in his Heaven and Hell, which he intended for the general public, but also in his Arcana coelestia (Heavenly Secrets) intended for the learned. Swedenborg arrives at this idea because he learned, in his contacts with the heavenly realm that—

It is an arcanum still unknown in the world that heaven reflects a single person if it is fully grasped, but in the heavens this is most common knowledge. Knowing this even in specifics and details is a specialty of the understanding of angels there. Many things follow from it, things which cannot be crisply and clearly conceptualized without this as their pervasive first principle. Since angles know that all of the heavens—even all of their communities—reflect a single person, they actually call heaven “the Greatest and Divine Man.” The term “Divine” is used because the Lord’s Divine makes heaven. [Emanuel Swedenborg, Heaven and Hell, VIII, §59]
Such ideas are jarring unless you get used to them—gradually. John von Neumann once said, and his quip applies elsewhere too, “In mathematics you don’t understand things. You just get used to them.” So let’s get used to the idea, for the moment, anyway. You can discard this, if you like, after you’ve absorbed the message here, namely that the heavens are organized “organically” into communities of angels that relate to Swedenborg’s “Grand Man,” the higher reality—and that what is in heaven has direct correspondences down here on earth. As above, so below, we might say, echoing Hermes.

With that, let me go on to the archangels of Mazdaism. In the theology of that religion we encounter, first of all, heavenly counterparts to every living individual here on earth; they are the fravartis—and if you’re reading this, Zoroastrians would say that you have a fravarti too. We also have, above them, holy beings, spentas, archangels, who have charge over—and importantly also act as guides for—humanity, animals, plants, fire and light (we might say energy), minerals, earth, and water. I learned of these matters in Henry Corbin’s Spiritual Body and Celestial Earth. That book contains a summary of the cosmology of Mazdaism. The formulation is much more ancient than Swedenborg’s, to be sure; Mazdaism, indeed, has been classified as the oldest known higher religion of humanity. Old it is, but the structure of this cosmology is functionally very similar to Swedenborg’s—and like Swedenborg’s correspondences between a material and a heavenly reality, we also find, in Mazdaism, the notion of interacting realms or dimensions a higher one above guiding and constituting the lower. The difference is that Mazdaism conceives of the upper realm as an infinite column of light rather than as a “Grand Man.” The column of light enfolds the heavens—and their mountains, rivers, waterfalls, plains, cities, and habitations. There too, as above, so below—but in the lower realm another column, of infinite darkness, is mixing with the light. And we, engaged in the work of the creation, will either succeed individually or descend into the darkness if we’re tempted by its allurements.

Now to complete this picture, I would offer the proposals of Rupert Sheldrake, a modern, living scientist. Sheldrake is a biologist. Sheldrake suggests that undetectable morphic fields exist and correspond to all material phenomena. They contain the forms and patterns of the material, not simply statically but dynamically as well, thus they also hold patterns of motion and behavior. And these fields are alive in the sense that they can and do change over time. They are a cosmic memory. And all things are in active contact with these fields at all times. We thus have a scheme that parallels Mazdaism: not only living entities but inorganic stuff also takes its guidance, as it were, from vast accumulations of highly organized banks of memory, the morphic fields. Fields exist at all levels and are hierarchically arranged. There would thus be a morphic field specific to mammals as well as for, say, rabbits and people, the latter fields hierarchically beneath the field for mammals. And above the field for mammals would be a more general field for all living entities. The interesting parallel here is that this undetectable but physical reality is proposed as a naturalistic explanation forced on us by looking at matter. We infer these fields from what we see on the ground—and we need the fields as a hypothesis in order to explain certain categories of events that, thus far, we cannot reduce to a chemical or a mechanical sets of causes. The embryo’s development is usually cited as an example. Our science has not been able, thus far, to offer what might be a hard chemico-mechanical explanation for the changes we actually behold.

Sheldrake’s most relevant works here are A New Science of Life. The Hypothesis of Formative Causation and Morphic Resonance and the Habits of Nature.

Swedenborg’s proposals, and Mazdaism, too, for that matter, are dismissed as outdated religious mumbo-jumbo. We’re beyond such things today. Sheldrake is dismissed on the grounds of parsimony, chopped away by Occam’s razor. Modern science says it doesn’t need yet another level of explanation. Just wait until we’ve figured things out the hard way, by patient experiment. All right. But that view—alongside the earlier mumbo-jumbo dismissal—depends on a hard commitment to the notion of materialism and its consequent affirmation of the meaninglessness of existence.

People like me don’t wish to make that commitment. And for those who don’t, the ideas sketched in here—just enough to become visible—can take on a certain level of interest. To delve deeper, of course, means to endure trials and tribulations not unlike those that science is condemned to accept. But these may lead to insight; those of science promise more of the same old, same old until the sun burns out.

Monday, March 22, 2010

The Angel Beckons

The title is my own and chosen for its context here, today. See the last post to understand it. The following is, again, from Rumi’s Divani Shamsi Tabriz XII.

Every form you see has its archetype in the placeless world;
If the form perished, no matter, since its original is everlasting.
Every fair shape you have seen, every deep saying you have heard,
Be not cast down that it perished; for that is not so.
Whereas the spring-head is undying, its branch gives water continually.
Since neither can cease, why are you lamenting?
Conceive the Soul as a fountain, and these created things as rivers:
While the fountain flows, the rivers run from it.
Put grief out of your head and keep quaffing this river water;
Do not think of the water failing; for this water is without end.
From the moment you came into the world of being,
A ladder was placed before you that you might escape.
First you were mineral, later you turned to plant,
Then you became animal: how should this be a secret to you?
Afterwards you were made man, with knowledge, reason, faith;
Behold the body, which is a portion of the dust-pit, how perfect it has grown!
When you have travelled on from man, you will doubtless become an angel;
After that you are done with this earth: your station is in heaven.
Pass again even from angelhood: enter that ocean,
That your drop may become a sea which is a hundred seas of ‘Oman.
Leave this ‘Son,’ say ever ‘One’ with all your soul;
If your body has aged, what matter, when the soul is young?


Jalal’ud-Din Rumi (1207-1273) was a Sufi mystic who lived most of his life in a region which is now Turkey. This poem was written in Farsi and the translation is by R.A. Nicholson.

Angels: A Short Overview

Too many articles on angels rapidly bog down. The become historical. They try to explain the twelve angelic orders and their arrangement into four angelic choirs. They delve into biblical references. They deal with the celebrities among the angels. And so on. They almost never touch the core issue that interests a traveler of the frontier. Are angels real? How do they fit the scheme of things.

Every culture believes in angels, but to make the differences clear, let me suggest the following. Only the Judeo-Christian-Muslim cultures—they are genuinely monotheistic and adhere to a belief in a single, all-powerful God—view angels as a distinct category of beings. They project three kinds of conscious beings: humans, angels, and God.

In most other cultures angels are classified as gods and goddesses; they are celestial beings. The higher gods are higher by degree, not in kind. The angelic form, therefore, is not specifically differentiated. Two examples. The equivalent of an angel in Hinduism is a deva, a god or goddess. The word itself is rooted in the concept of the celestial, shining, or luminous. In Mazdaism all beings are conceived to have a fravarti, thus a celestial counterpart; we are twinned with our guardian angel, as it were. And angels of collectives exist as well. Mazdaism might be considered an angelology. In all systems, not least in the Christian, these spirits may be good or bad, and the bad ones are demons.

Staying with the Asian approach for just a moment longer, we see there that the distinction between humans and higher spirits is continuous. Humans are fallen sparks of the divine. The devas are the same sparks at a higher level. The difference is one of condition, not of essence. Only in the western conception are angels a specially created order. And in the Muslim conception (but notably not in Muslim mysticism, e.g., in the writings of Rumi) angels are functions; they’re strictly messengers of God without a will of their own.

The Asian view, which happens to be the view of the majority of humans, has only two rather limited parallels in the West. Swedenborg—and the churches that follow his teaching—hold that angels are simply highly advanced humans, that all angels began as humans—as did all demonic souls. Here is a quote from Swedenborg’s Heaven and Hell which makes this point succinctly:

People in the Christian world are totally unaware that heaven and hell come from the human race. They actually believe that angels were created in the beginning and constitute heaven, and that the devil or Satan was an angel of light who became rebellious and was cast out together with his faction, and that this gave rise to hell.

Angels are utterly amazed that there can be this kind of belief in the Christian world, and even more so that people know absolutely nothing about heaven, even though this is a primary doctrine of the church. Knowing that this kind of ignorance is prevalent, they are profoundly delighted that it has now pleased the Lord to reveal to us so much about heaven — and about hell as well—and so as much as possible to dispel the darkness that is rising daily because this church [Swedenborg means this era] is drawing to a close. [Emanuel Swedenborg, Heaven and Hell, §311]
One faith that arose from the Muslim, and strictly-speaking the Shi’ite branch of Islam, has views almost identical to Swedenborg’s. They are the Baha’is.

Interesting, isn’t it? We have a rather ancient grouping of Asian traditions—and tiny minorities in the west—both of which suggest an interestingly parsimonious explanation of the angelic phenomenon. Together these views suggest that a single created conscious agency suffices to explain higher created beings existing beneath the Ultimate creator’s throne. And we belong into that category right alongside angels. The division of this community—which I like to call the soul community—into three parts is based on the operation of our free will. Some are demonic because they’re headed downward, some are embodied, and some are celestial because they are moving upward through the infinite reaches of reality. The explanation of that status in the middle, thus of the souls encased in bodies differs. The Asians view it as part of a descent; we were drawn by the desire for limited experience; in Swedenborg’s view we are experiencing the first state of life as newly created souls.

This will serve as a very general introduction to this subject. To see a much more sophisticated view of the place of the angelic in the order of creation, as described by the immortal poet, Jalal’ud-Din Rumi, a Sufi, I suggest that you read the next post.

Saturday, March 20, 2010

The Mood or You?

The proposition I’d like to develop is that the body’s condition can cause mental states—and vice versa. If we are foiled in some endeavor or we get bad news, our body will obediently mirror our state of depression or anxiety—although it’s in perfectly good shape. But similarly a physically low period, low for whatever reasons, will also affect our attitudes—and what we viewed yesterday with perfect equanimity will today strike us as troubling or ominous. Unless we watch ourselves, bodies and minds can act as amplifiers.

So what comes first? The mood or you?

The body has its cycles. Biorhythms are not considered to be scientifically established, but they are matters of experience. Some people are very sensitive and feel these waves of up and down quite sharply. Some are so insensitive they’re able to sail along in a more or less permanent state of equilibrium. Such people tend also to be insensitive to their own inner states—which actually helps in mood control. If you tend to be moody, you’ll know that perfectly well. It is moody people who benefit from pondering this subject at all. Only they consider the perpetually cheery as sometimes a royal pain in the ass. They sometimes want to dive into the depth and be bloody well left alone.

My own belief, based on self-observation, is that moods are caused by the body—and this in two ways. First, bodies have their lows and highs, and these recur at regular intervals. When they are low they affect the mind—but they affect it only if the mind is closely identified with the body—and the person, the real us, doesn’t do anything about it. The mind thus amplifies the body’s state. Second, bodies are obedient servants. If we are distraught and frustrated, they will obediently produce the necessary chemical states to mirror at the physical level what we feel mentally. Now, of course, being physically listless and moping does not help us solve our problems. Those bodily routines tend to minimize activity, not least clear thought. There the body, mirroring the mind, isn’t actually helping—but then it doesn’t have a mind of its own.

The conclusion here is that—despite whatever we might think about it—we are masters of our mood provided that we make the effort. But that effort requires, as the very first step, a realization of this truth. Once it’s there, the resulting change in our mental states is often quite rapid. The realization is an act of detachment. Another way to put this is to say that we can stop identifying with the feeling of depression or anxiety—figuratively step aside from ourselves, look at ourselves as “the other.” The body will also—and immediately—begin to mirror this new state of the mind. It will stop pumping chemicals. I sometimes feel an immediate lift in my energies.

Now, of course, there is a paradox here. The mood clouds our thought so that the realization does not arise. For this reason, preparation—call it “setting traps”—must take place when we are feeling normal. We must cultivate the habit of detachment—and engage in a kind of “remembering” of ourselves at frequent intervals. Taking just a moment, half of a minute, just to look around and become aware, can become a habit of mind. And we must also in anticipation of the onset of moods decide to come awake when we feel ourselves slipping into darker states.

With practice, then, later on, the mere thought will often work immediately. In the early stages of this kind of exercise, ritual acts are often very helpful. They serve to get the mule’s attention. It’s best to do something dramatically different, to break our routine. In my case cleaning the bathroom or getting out the vacuum will usually serve. Some people put on running shoes. Taking out a fresh sheet and beginning a diary entry—a very good method that. Those who keep diaries are working on themselves. The point is to stop the flow of gloom, to divert the self, to refocus its attention.

The mood is a product of nature, you might say. We must include the social under this heading too—the strictly human—not least the mood in the office, the workplace, the mood on the news, the weather, or our own physical state, not least fatigue. You—namely the person, the agent, the soul—you are sovereign and above it all. You are indestructible. If you refuse the grace of your attention to something, it is amazing how rapidly that thing or phenomenon will shrink into the nothingness it actually is compared to the sovereign you.

* * *

Here by way of additional notes, a few more points. Brigitte (the better half) points out that biofeedback is a relevant example. We can do amazing things when we are wired up, not least influence a single neuron’s action in our brain. Brigitte points out that the feedback mechanism enables our sovereign self to act on the body because it has a precise target for its powerful tool—the attention.

In all of the above, of course, I refer to moods arising in a normal, healthy body. Such bodies will do our will—and continue to do so while undamaged. But there is such a thing as clinical depression; in that case medical assistance is also required. Pain is another difficult area. We cannot stop the body doing its job—of which the signaling of pain is a perfectly normal task. What we can do by such practices is to minimize pain and to stop it possessing us against our will.

Finally, the self’s superiority to the body is exemplified, occasionally, by wondrous stories such as of a woman lifting a car just long enough to free a child—that sort of thing is viewed as miraculous until we realize that such an act mobilizes energies in that body it didn’t think it had—or that the fierce will found forces that, while they invisibly surround us, might be in certain circumstances channeled into the organism to help it do impossible things.

Friday, March 19, 2010

The Mystery of Chi

Two posts back I have suggested that the Chinese concept of chi is present in every culture under other names, and I recited some of them: baraka, prana, and our own concept of grace. We also have a more secular version of it, the élan vital, the life force. In actual use these words often have quite different emphases and connotations. A good example is our use of the word grace. In the religious context it is seen as a special gift from God or a state of being without sin (“state of grace”); in the social context it connotes good upbringing, charm, advanced behavior, fluidity of movement; and then there is “grace under fire.”

All of these uses of the word suggest a kind of elevated state or mode of being; the last phrase is instructive because it suggests holding on to our humanity even when all hell breaks loose. An equivalent of it, the French sang-froid, has the same connotation: cold blooded, thus above the natural state. But notice that in our usage, grace is never equated with the life force as such, whereas it is strongly linked to that concept in Asia. Our usage is the product of our culture, a product of our system of classification. We’re very conceptual. We like to separate. We’ve separated grace from the life force—and this despite the fact that our founding book, the Bible, in Genesis 2:7, tells us that God “breathed into his nostrils the breath of life.” That breath, I would suggest, is chi. The dust of which God formed the body is matter.

Now, mind you, speaking of such matters we’re engaged in the pursuit higher forms of knowledge than our science can ever hope to reach. We’re in the realms of poetry. Poetry’s favorite subject, love, is as foreign to science as is life. The poet dares to call them one and the same thing; science is silent on both. This subject is also ultimately foreign to philosophical approaches unless these acknowledge a higher realm, the realm of revelation. Conceptual approaches cannot capture the essence here, which must be experienced. Concepts divide, poetry unites. But poetry unites without destroying crucial differences that manifest in experience. Indeed the more precise our conceptual understanding becomes, the more it shatters the unity of experience—whereas the life force has the magical result of fusing—without destroying—a vast diversity of materially distinct entities into a unified organism.

One way to get a better feel for the mystery of chi is to picture this fluid, this breath of the divine, as present in everything that lives—and, by organizing matter, becoming visible. At the level of ordinary life—and that dusty little weed growing in the crack of my concrete drive is alive—we might think of chi as already and miraculously present. It announces itself. For all we know it’s also present in the inorganic realm. It may be that energy which defies the laws of inertia and keeps electrons swirling around atomic nuclei. Where do those electrons get their force? And why don’t they ever run down? Those electrons are still swirling, moving, glowing even in the coldest rocks on the frozen continent of Antarctica. And we, ourselves, seem to be made of innumerably many perpetua mobile. Chi may permeate the cosmos. It may be the strong force that keeps the quarks clinging to each other to form protons and neutrons inside the atomic core. In those tiny entities—and they are mere inferences so far as we really know—the energy is invisible. In living things it’s manifest—but, for us, it’s not particularly remarkable. Familiarity breeds contempt. That dusty weed mostly reminds me to pull it. But chi also manifests in much more mysterious and higher form—as grace. And in that form, once more, it becomes invisible. We can, however, still experience it. We experience it as beauty, harmony, intelligence, and benevolence—real phenomena that escape reduction to the visible forms that carry it. That music isn’t violins or black dots on white paper. The grace of that building isn’t merely stone.

This sort of view of chi, poetic and therefore unifying, might be dismissed as a fuzzy sort of pantheism. But what it suggests to me is actually a glimpse into the very structure of reality. I conceive of it as consisting of three distinct but closely related elements always in interaction: matter, energy, and self. Staying with the Chinese modes of naming these things, the first is yin, the receptive, the second yang, the creative, and the third is the Tao. We would call it God, the ultimate Self. A proper view of this structure, I would suggest, emerges when we imagine that the same constituent elements exist at every level of reality, not merely here in on earth. This would suggest that matter has its higher or subtle forms as well—beyond the border I keep talking about. So does energy. So does self, writ small or large. And in that case we get a conceptually sharper view of chi or grace in the bargain. Here is how I would argue that:

What appears as simple energy to us—thus solar power, for example—is chi as it manifests in a lower order of reality. What we call life is that same energy already intensified to a higher pitch, but still embedded in the lower order. It is a sign of a transition between orders, the prelude to entry into the next “mansion” that exists above ours. Living here we’re poised between dimensions, at the very point of transition. What we call grace is the life present in the heavenly reaches touching this one but only, alas, ever so lightly. To have it more abundantly, as suggested in John 10:10, we must cross over.

Thursday, March 18, 2010

Angels

[Jacob] dreamed, and behold a ladder set up on earth, and the top of it reached to heaven: and behold the angels of God ascending and descending on it. [Genesis 28:12]

He shall give his angels charge over thee, to keep thee in all thy ways. [Psalms 91:11]

Angels are bright still, though the brightest fell. [Shakespeare, Macbeth IV, iii, 22]

The eyes open to a cry of pulleys,
And spirited from sleep, the astounded soul
Hangs for a moment bodiless and simple
As false dawn.
Outside the open window
The morning air is all awash with angels.
[Richard Purdy Wilbur, Love Calls Us to the Things of This World, 1956]

I looked over Jordan and what did I see? …
A band of angels coming after me,
Coming for to carry me home.
[Swing Low, Sweet Chariot]

“Pass in, pass in,” the angels say,
“In to the upper doors,
Nor count compartments of the floors,
But mount to paradise
By the stairway of surprise.”
[Ralph Waldo Emerson. Merlin I]




* * *

Angels are a fascinating and deep subject worth pondering. A post on the subject is in the making, but I thought I’d introduce it in this manner, touching on some views of angels over time in quotes. If you want to read a poem of mine about angels, with some appended paragraphs from Swedenborg, see this post on Ghulf Genes. I collect my poems on that site, although that poem, and an earlier companion to it, reachable here, belong in the context of the borderzone.

--------------------
The painting is by Hieronymus Bosch, Ascent of the Blessed. Bosch (1450-1516), a Dutch painter, long predates any modern discussions of near-death experiences in many of which tunnels with a light at the end—and sometimes pairs of guides or helpers, and a luminous being present at arrival—became common enough to be abbreviated as NDEs.

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Pondering Action

In a comment on “Pondering Desolation,” Monique wonders why the life of action is so distracting and compelling—and why it produces imbalances with undesirable results. Good points. Her comment reminded me that life on the frontier, and here of course I mean life on the borderzone, has its own solution to the demand for “action in the world.” We are, after all, supposed to be in the world if not of it. The Sufi tradition is but one of others that calls for realizing spiritual values in the world—but it is a tradition that gives this matter emphasis. In that tradition withdrawal into solitudes—and celibacy, for that matter—are seen as temporary practices to strengthen the individual for the life of action.

I would also note here that in Asia the martial arts, and related practices derived from it, like Tai chi chuan, directly link physical with spiritual action. And there is also the body of useful western observations about types of personalities—inner- and outer-directed (introverts and extroverts), sometimes linked to body types (somatotypes). This last concept was developed by the psychologist William Herbert Sheldon and studied at Yale. Sheldon proposed three body types called endomorphs, mesomorphs, and ectomorphs, roughly associated with personality types that are gregarious-social, active-muscular-athletic, and inward-sensitive-cerebral. People are, or tend toward, one or the other of these. Thus we may be drawn into the social whirl or the world of action by our own temperament. But beneath our temperaments we are all souls, and ways of life that let us express our given natures at the highest form have been developed over time.

I’ve always felt that the Chinese concept of chi, rudely rendered as life force, is perhaps the key to the spiritual life—no matter what our constitution. Four strangers, all from different parts of the world—in a time before English became a world language—met at a tavern and decided to journey together. Some days later they came across an orchard, and all four cried out in delight. One saw cherries, another one les cerise, a third one die kirschen, a fourth called them cseresnye. They saw the same fruit—a sweet red berry with a stone in the middle. The Asian chi or qi, ki, or gi is another’s baraka, the third person’s grace, a fourth traveler’s prana, and so on.

Why does chi flow more readily in the desolation of the desert, on the peak of rocky mountains? Because the distractions of the world have been minimized. Our genuine happiness derives from increasing and concentrating the flow of grace; unhappiness rises when this flow is rapidly dispersed or blocked by endless distractions. The modern error is to confuse baraka with ordinary life energy of the sort we get from carbohydrates. If it were only that, mere over-eating would make us saints. The wisdom of the traditions lies in recognizing that this energy is of another dimensionality, above that of the coarser kind. It is subtle but, when present, of tremendous potency. In very concentrated form it will cure ills spontaneous and more, much more…

The key to spiritualizing action seems to be concentration. The key to concentration is detachment—not in the sense of withdrawal but in the sense of presence. This demands the cultivation of a peculiar sort of duality within ourselves. We must be present to ourselves while simultaneously attending to the action before us. This may sound weird and contradictory, but it isn’t. What we must detach from is identification with the constant upwelling of emotional reaction to anything and everything. It is that automatic commentary of our habit selves—sometimes a whisper, sometimes a shouting, sometimes rage, sometimes hysteria—which actually distracts us. Action only requires seeing the facts, understanding them, selecting the right action—and then doing it. Without commentary. When the phone rings just as we start typing a sentence, the mind shouts, God dammit! I hope that’s not…whatever. A centered self, a concentrated self, a self that has prepared itself in the morning with appropriate meditation—renewed at intervals—will simply…pick up the telephone. The three dots I placed there stand for an inward pause, a conscious breath to suppress the shouting; it’s a reminder.

Yes, yes, already. But it’s hard. — And it is. But in a real sense the distractions are all internal. What’s out there is just the bombardment of facts. The distraction arises when we let them—distract us. From our intention. Our intention to act. We want to focus on something—and therefore, interrupted, we lose our focus. The trick is not to lose our focus even in the midst of interruptions. The result of this, if assiduously cultivated, is that the atmosphere will cool. The mind will become more disciplined. Slowly. Gradually. The flow of chi will increase, less of it will be blown away into the winds of emotion. We will become more efficient. The lower self is in many ways quite like an animal and requires long and tedious training—and retraining. And again.

My own experience is that practices of this type wear out after a while. As I succeed in organizing my own action better, as things calm down, I tend to ease up on the discipline and then over days I gradually slip back into bad habits. But the upside is that each succeeding effort is more successful, and even in these matters habits do build, not least the habit of just clearing the desk when I feel myself getting hysterical—putting the To Do list aside, overcoming the terror and panic of doing so—and beginning all over again with a session of reminders and a forcible recall of what it’s all about. It works—if we do. We learned that last motto, years ago, from Laura Huxley.

I’ll have more to say on this subject. The whole reality of chi and grace has many more interesting aspects. The teachings of Montessori were centered on natural concentration as a “normalizing” phenomenon. I’ll get to it. It’s on the To Do list.

Monday, March 15, 2010

An Outline of Cosmologies

All kinds of cosmologies vie and have always vied for recognition, with one or another dominating particular times and cultures. Cosmologies, ultimately, answer the most important Why-question that occurs to us: “Why are we here on earth?” Over the months I’ve put up discussions of these cosmologies. The general interest in this subject is close to nil, I realize. The posts rank close to the bottom of subjects I’ve pondered here. Oh, well. I’ll add another one. In this post I’d like to present an outline of cosmology considering only the meaningful kind. Materialism is, I propose, meaningless. Its assertion is that all is matter or some derivate therefore, that all that happens happens because matter is organized in a certain way—and by chance. Using the word matter, as always, I include energy as one form of it. Materialist cosmologies don’t interest me. Herewith then an outline followed by some brief comments.

I. We are here because we were sent here.
     A. We were already in being when we were sent here.
          1. We were sent here by an unconscious agency.
          2. We were sent here by a conscious agency superior to us.
               a. We were sent here in the course of a natural process of development.
               b. We were sent here as a kind of banishment.
     B. We were created and placed into bodies.
          1. Embodied existence is our natural place in the order of nature.
          2. Embodied existence is the first stage in a more complex existence.

II. We are here because we chose to be here.
     A. We came because something attracted us - curiosity, challenge, some positive cause.
     B. We came because we wished to get away - assertiveness, rebellion, a negative cause.

The two big divisions in this Tree of Choice is whether or not our being here was involuntary or voluntary. What most of us know is that we don’t remember any earlier existence. But that doesn’t mean that we did not exist. The very fact of being in this dimension may also explain our lack of memories. We may well have preexisted our birth; and in another “life” may have chosen to be here. Thus the choices presented are legitimate.

If we came here involuntarily but we were already in being, the issue of memory is pertinent. If we were created at the conception of our bodies or a little later (once that event was held to be a little later), the memory problem is moot. To be sure, some people remember a previous life in childhood, which clouds that whole subject.

In both of the big options (sent or chose) the assumption is that something created us—thus that we’re not self-created. Some may object by citing Hindu or Kabbalistic beliefs that souls are tiny sparks of divinity. But a part is not a whole. And in that context the moment of separation, of the spark from the whole, may be understood as the moment of an individual’s creation.

In Option I.A. (we were sent but we were already there, somewhere else) I present two choices. The first of these might be labeled “Cosmic Disaster,” thus some kind of event that simply happened—and in doing so disorganized the dimension in which we were—disorganized it enough so that we had to find another kind and, by implication, an inferior kind of home. That “home” is material existence. This choice, as it stands, assumes a naturalistic framework in the cosmos where conscious communities exist, can’t be destroyed, but their environments can be changed by events over which the communities have no control.

The second choice presented is that Divine Providence caused us to be sent into an inferior world for one of two reasons. In the first (2.a.) it was to unfold our potential through a process of development. The second (2.b.) represents the consequence of free acts that result in a some kind of failure to develop, to conform, to participate, or, in general, to obey the prevailing laws; we could call this punishment, but is more properly rendered as a consequence. In my lexicon God doesn’t punish but does create the environment, not least its limits—that we overstep at our own peril.

Option I.B. (we were created as our bodies formed) is the prevailing view of Christianity. Here I elaborate that option by presenting the Thomistic view (2.a.) namely that Reality describes a hierarchy of beings. In that reality the human presence has a certain fixed place in a hierarchy, both matter and spirit. Below us is matter, above us is immaterial spirit. Here the traumas of earthly existence and of death are explained as the Fall, thus corresponding to a negative choice on our part that disturbed the cosmic harmony, but it shall be righted in the end when we are resurrected into glorified bodies. The second sub-sub option here (2.b.) assumes that a bodily existence is the first stage of a much longer course of future existence in which physical bodies such as we here possess will no longer be needed. Thus it corresponds to the developmental option above it under I.A.

Turning now to the second big option (we chose to be here), I subdivided that into two categories. The first (II.A.) represents a positive option (however nasty it might actually feel in practice). We are here because we were drawn to this dimension. You might say that we volunteered; indeed that is the essence of Mazdaism; we volunteered to participate in the creation. A less dramatic form of that is that soul communities encountered the material realm, became fascinated with it, and, descending into it, often find that state unpleasant. They are released from it at death—and may escape if they can overcome the “attraction” of the lower realm.

The second (II.B.) presents a negative option. It corresponds to the willful word of Lucifer who, pronouncing that he wouldn’t serve (Non serviam) fell from the heavens with his following. This option suggests that we are part of a rebellious soul community members of which, having now tasted of this dimension, are having second thoughts and are split into those willing to return and others who are still inclined to stay at arm’s length.

I’ve excluded from the scheme above the Gnostic conceptualization. It asserts that the cosmos was created by a secondary god, an aberrant angelic being. That low-level creator is usually called the Demiurge. I omit that variant because it merely creates a conceptually unnecessary layer in which the whole idea of a Fall is semi-deified. I put this exclusion here because it helps to see the scheme before this variant is mentioned.

Thursday, March 11, 2010

Pondering Desolation

I picture the borderzone as a thinly populated region, indeed as a desert where the wind blows and the sand flies, where the sun stares fiercely down at desolation and the sky at night’s a thick, rich brilliance of stars, but rare indeed the hermit who wanders these wastes and communes with barely visible clumps of dusty vegetation and mosses that, here and there, lend the rocks a somber, greenish hue.

What people want is cures from ills, a job, and help in love relations. Strange theories of origins and soaring speculation, wonder at the meaning of it all—the overwhelming numbers—thus billions of galaxies, and never mind just one of them that holds 200 billion stars like ours—all such things are beyond comprehension and light years distant from the busy brain driving in thick traffic in the morning while it rehearses items on a crowded list of things to do.

Nonetheless—and I look back on quite a crowded life—it seems to me that my passage through its turbulence—the turbidity of pools as ibn el-Arabi once described it—has been greatly blessed by the occasional hour I’ve forced relentless Schedule to yield me for such contemplations. The descent into matter must have been attractive. What did it promise? I do wonder… A resolution of the mysteries--now that I’ve finally reached the basics? Going, I think, in the wrong direction, all the while, in seeking the ultimate answer? What I’ve found, instead, is that in that direction lies the shatter rather than the unity, and that the approach to a kind of silence, symbolized by deserts, empty spaces, and what only seems like desolation produces riches far beyond whatever might be on that shopping list even after I’ve won the lottery, and I don’t mean the ordinary kind. I mean the big one.