Pages

Sunday, May 20, 2012

The Attraction of the Natural

Traveling in the Borderzone in contrast to visiting occasionally—which is all a busy life permits—means to be alone or, what amounts to the same thing, to be interested in odd matters most people can’t or don’t bother to fathom and think kinda weird. Here comes one of those. I’ve long found the naturalistic far more attractive than the arbitrary explanations of reality. On the one side things evolve, flow, change, emanate. On the other God created everything. Mind you, the poetics of Genesis manage to do both. Its leading verse contains the latter in a sharply rendered concept (“created”); its second the former as wondrous images:

In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth. The earth was without form and void, and darkness was upon the face of the deep; and the Spirit of God was moving over the face of the waters. [Genesis 1:1-2]

The naturalistic view is that paragraph if stripped of any conscious agency, a meaning that the word “created” unmistakably carries. The first sentence would be missing; the second would replace “Spirit of God” by “energy.” Energy introduces motion without endowing it with the features of a person, an agent.

The attraction of the natural arises in me because that’s what I see at the large scale—thus, say, looking out at the sky, with or without a telescope, or down at the earth from orbit. The sun is blazing but nothing tells me Why. It is so great that, when it finally goes into its death stage, it will extend out and way beyond the earth. The earth will simply melt away in its heat. And yet this thing is but a microscopic little thing in one galaxy—and our galaxy is one of countlessly many. From space, at least by sunlight, the earth may have a vague green sheen, here and there, but life, as such, is quite invisible, the merest rash a few degrees of centigrade, either way, would rapidly eradicate. Nothing about this gives us any explanations, and the scale is such that it is incommensurable with the human—or even the blue jay-ish.

The maddening aspect of the naturalistic, however, is that it simply doesn’t cover everything. It works up to the level of life. The chaos can yield different kinds of atoms that will then attract or repel each other and thus form various bodies by a cosmic evolution provided that the chaos is moved by “energy.” To be sure, by adding motion, as such, we are already introducing an agency, by the back door, as it were, but never mind. What the naturalistic does not cover, not at all, is the life phenomenon. And least of all human self-awareness.

Pantheism is great at a distance but becomes very problematical up close—thus when we encounter either end-seeking form-preservation or consciousness. What all modern naturalistic systems attempt, vainly, of course, is to explain how the lifeless can suddenly take on life, the purposeless develop purpose, and the mindless evolve mind ex nihilo. These explanations have trended from the mechanistic to the ever more ephemeral. Each advance in physics has had its corresponding exploitation by cosmology. Thus we have the clockwork universe, then atoms, then quanta, then morphic fields, and last complexity, whatever that is, sort of floating in the air or hiding in the core of reality, with a tropism for increasing itself; until minds form.

Temperamentally I am a naturalist. But when it gets down to decision time I’m forced, by the very logic of things, to side with the arbitrary, which is to assert that the only way we can squeeze any meaning out of this chaos is to discern invisibly behind it a genuine conscious agent. Its flowing garments, while they may not be fully alive still carry a kind of impress or memory of their creator, and that emanation itself is what makes the natural world magical and attractive. But there is something inexpressibly more wondrous beneath.

Saturday, May 19, 2012

Fractal Aging

One characteristic of reaching advanced age is that the patterns have become all too familiar. Not that we know much. Nobody really does. But any effort to dig deeply into the details of something will in old age predictably reveal patterns already encountered numerous times before. That sentiment is echoed in Ecclesiastes 1:9: “What has been is what will be, and what has been done is what will be done; and there is nothing new under the sun.” So how old was Solomon—assuming he dictated his wisdom in advancing age? Wikipedia grants him 80 years but without presenting any evidence for that; the Jewish Virtual Library scatters some dates from which I derive maximally 69. In any case, old enough—especially if you had circa 1,000 wives…

Thinking about this feeling—that “same old” feeling—brings to mind tracing, say, a Mandelbrot or Julia fractal image to ever greater levels of magnification, and while the vistas keep changing and can be beautiful, interesting, even mesmerizing, the patterns remain the same.

For this reason alone—ignoring the fact that with advancing age the body gradual weakens, stiffens, hardens—at my age the notion of extending life beyond the standard three-score and ten or, these days, fourscore, is not all that attractive. And supposing science could deliver augmentations, let me call them, so that we could live to be two hundred, three hundred while yet retaining bodies that function as they do in their late forties, early fifties, why, the prospects would not be all that attractive. That would mean working for many more decades with all that that implies for the ordinary human: layoffs, new managements, reorgs, off-sites, airports, committee-meetings, deadlines, budgets, on and blessed on. That same old would soon take on a quite toxic flavor; life would become quite burdensome. And a feature of that future society would be, it seems to me, that the majority of deaths in that evil future would be by suicide. A sci-fi story lurks here, come to think of it, but, come to thinks of it, I’ve already been there and done that.
---------------
The Julia set image courtesy of Wikipedia, by someone called Eequor. Link.

Thursday, May 17, 2012

Going with the Flow

The Russian philosopher Nicolai Berdyaev (1874-1948) pictured time as a horizontal flow—and eternity abruptly intersecting it from above like the strike of a lightning bolt. I think I read that in The Beginning and the End. I’ve always appreciated near-poetic imagery in place of abstract expressions. Here Berdyaev captures the almost ungraspable dimensional differences between this world and another by using a vivid image. Not surprisingly, Berdyaev was also a philosopher of creativity. We can better picture it, but there is also a way to experience that difference in our ordinary here and now.

The Naqshbandi order of the Sufis has long taught eleven rules or practices intended to advance human development. Of these the ninth is called “Temporal Pause” or “Pause of Time.” In more abbreviated form it is known as “Stop.”  What the practice intends is that, for a moment, long or short, we remove ourselves from that much-lauded activity, going with the flow. That last phrase is used to describe pleasurable spontaneous activity, but in truth we’re always going with the flow. We’re creatures of habits and impulses, impulses arising from associations and habits guiding their satisfaction. Examining a whole day will reveal just how automatic all of our actions have been, no matter how complex and “intellectual” they might have been in content. Even when we are engaged in quite purposive activities, the purposes themselves are part of our habituation. We might look long and hard before we encounter a “temporal pause,” and if we meet it at all, it will itself have been caused by some (usually negative) news. The “pause in time,” however, to be effective, must be deliberate. Another aspect of it is that it should, for all intents and purposes, be unwelcome to our personality, our habit self, what the Sufis call the Commanding Self. It is nothing other than our programming. It might have elements within it introduced by actual deliberate effort long ago, but these have been, as it were, automated.

We shouldn’t want to do it—but we do it anyway. When I’m engaged in something (e.g., writing this) and the telephone rings—that irritates me; I feel an inner violence I have to bring under control; that too, of course, becomes habitual, sublimated into a sigh. It is an unwanted Stop. But when I get up from the keyboard to take a sheet of paper at my desk and settle to half-an-hour’s diary writing, my personality is still resistant—but not quite in the same way. After all, it is the boss who wants to do this boring thing. Other forms of the temporal pause are prayer, meditation, going on walks (especially when these are of some duration and it’s hot or cold), other forms of strenuous exercise, and, for some people, sitting down and reading a book.

That pause in time, when the necessary conditions are present, thus when I’d rather be doing something else, when my motive is precisely to interrupt the flow, then it yields unusual results. Can such things become habitual? Not if I don’t really want to do them. The paradox is that the pause only works when it is resistance to the flow. The results show that.

Stopping time—and this sort of action is actually stopping time—because what we call time is the flow—suddenly changes our usual perspective. In a while the body begins to reflect this new state. It calms down. Anxieties recede. Important things become less so. The boredom we anticipated dissipates. We’re still in time, but no longer of it. The exercise, in various forms, does something for me, always positive. Whereas three or four days spent in the flow exclusively produces quite different atmospherics; therefore I know that it is time to Stop. We don’t have the eyes to let us see what actually happens when we remove ourselves from time into eternity. But there is a feeling there. Years ago, trying to find a word for it, I began to call it sovereignty. All genuinely deliberate thought and action arises from this central something. The flow temps us incessantly, but we shy from making use of a great gift that is entirely within our grasp.

Monday, May 14, 2012

Why Babies Cry at Birth

Birth and death are in a way equivalent experiences. They represent transitions—one from a state we don’t remember, the other to a state we don’t yet know. This applies to most of us. On entry into what we here call life, our memories of any pre-existence are effectively suspended—except for the handful who, for a while, remember previous lives. The latter also remember a death, and it came before this new life had its start. Those few who’ve undergone near-death experiences also have memories that at least suggest what such memories might be like.

Their reports suggest that death is rather ordinary, indeed abrupt. Ahead of it come memories of accidents or hospitalizations and then a state of detached awareness without pain. In many of these cases the person hears doctors, nurses in agitated states pronouncing that the patient’s dead. The subject then protests: “No, I’m not. I’m still alive! Here I am!” But the patient isn’t heard.

Perhaps it is a blessing that our consciousness is blanked out at birth and that our new brains cannot yet link to accumulated memories of our longer past, if any. Then babies might cry even harder. “No, no, no! Not that old trip again! Oh, my God. High school. Still ahead. Again!” To be sure the healthy-minded might look forward to all that, the cheerleading, the hazing, the Letter, the quest for popularity. For non-participants birth signals joy, death sorrow. If we but knew it, participants’ reactions may be the exact reverse.

If we but knew it. But all that we actually know is what we experience here—plus what amount to marginal and indistinct whispers suggesting that we might be wrong. Hence we view this life as immeasurably precious—if it’s our own and not the life of a chicken we chew or the lives we send drones to terminate. Do I remember being upset at waking in this world? I don’t. But I do recall some doubts distinctly. As for what lies ahead, for that I have my least-favorite apostle’s judgment. Oh death, where is thy sting? Oh grave, where is thy victory? 1 Corinthians 15:55.

Sunday, May 13, 2012

Sick-Mindedness

The subject of adequacy, touched on in my last post, has corollaries that throw a light on various stands that people take: atheism, agnosticism, belief, and so on. We operate under an assumption of absolute human equality, which is true enough when we view ourselves as physical beings, but even at the physical level there are exceptions to the rule when we include various handicaps people have at birth or acquire by accidents: the blind, the deaf, the mute, the paralyzed.  

Some experiences leave a much deeper imprint than others. One such for me was reading William James’ The Varieties of Religious Experience as a freshman in college—indeed I was reading him in the auditorium awaiting the first event, the welcoming ceremony. It introduced me to the notion that there may be at least two different kinds of people. James called these sick-minded and healthy-minded; the words he used are highly revealing of a bias, of course. The first kind have a vastly different experience of religion than the second; for the second it is a social, for the first an inner something. Indeed, reading that book then, I reacted aggressively to the term, sick-minded. I was then a convinced atheist; yet I knew myself to belong to that category nonetheless.

Sick-minded? Why that designation? Those who are sensitive to currents in reality that reach beyond the strictly physical and social tend to be less smoothly adapted to the world. There are things out there, felt, perceived, but never seen—but, for this type of person, real. Sensitivity is one way to described it; awake is another—awake to something more. Now if there is something more than atoms and electromagnetism out there, the sick-minded are more adapted, not less. But the healthy-minded, who don’t feel these currents much, feel more at home—because those currents point beyond this realm.

The interesting difference here is that we can all share (handicaps aside) the physical realities; but sharing realities that manifest beyond the reach of sensory organs is possible only with those who also sense them. Those capacities are internal, invisible, and beyond “objective,” meaning material, reach. I may know I have a soul, but I can’t trot it out and have it dance for you—whether it is a graceful ballet or a Ka Mate rugby haka.

The reality of the Beyond that the sick-minded feel also ultimately escapes intellectual approaches. Words, concepts, signify “things,” existences. If those things are physical, objective, tangible, measurable, they belong to the objective category and are thus matters about which people can constructively argue. But those things that lack this physical characteristic, i.e., they are inner phenomena, can only be discussed by those who “see” them. Therefore intellectual debate about God’s existence, let us say, or realms beyond, angels and principalities, are only possible between people who are adequate. All else belongs to the struggle for ordinary power in which, alas, both sick- or healthy-minded people tend to engage—until they know better.

Saturday, May 12, 2012

Tonalities of Being

If someone is incapable of hearing the difference between intervals of a fifth and a fourth, a musical career is not recommended. If a friend of yours cannot achieve a grasp of verb declensions, you will not take any lofty linguistic or philological ambitions seriously. Similarly, we must recognize that there exists a certain tonality of being which conditions perception of philosophical and religious facts. If this perception is lacking, better to pursue some entirely different field. [Henry Corbin in The Voyage and the Messenger, a collection of lectures and essays, North Atlantic Books, 1998, p. 5-6]

Around here we (read members of the family) were much taken with E.F. Schumacher’s book, A Guide for the Perplexed, years ago. In that he discusses the concept of adequacy, taken from the scholastic concept of adequatio rei et intellectus, thus the correspondence between the “thing” and the understanding of it. Sounds dry, but isn’t. I have the suspicion that St. Thomas and many others of that era meant something much more, using the word “intelligence,” than that word has come to mean in our times. The subtlety of that word, adequacy, becomes nicely visible in the quote from Henry Corbin; Corbin’s examples carry the wider meaning nicely. He means what people say when they have problems translating an understanding into concepts but say, instead, “I know it when I see it.” Hence Corbin’s nice word, tonalities. Music escapes the usual approach which must break things in order to parse them, and in the breaking something escapes the definition.

Adequacy has served us well. It makes one tolerant of those who simply cannot hear the music.

Thursday, May 10, 2012

What Is, Is?

Material reality is all that we see and it is therefore compelling. We exist before we know that we do; we’re aware of being very early, but not of being selves. For all of us—I think that everyone experiences it, but I can’t be sure—a moment comes later when self-awareness suddenly erupts.  It happens in childhood. At that moment our human life begins. No sudden memories of having been before accompany our abrupt awakenings.  And by that time we’re so habituated to our bodies and surroundings that self-awareness isn’t felt as anything radical. The last thing we think at that moment is that it’s odd that we are here. The moment, indeed, doesn’t last long. In a minute or two we’re back to doing our usual things—at that age play or exploration.

We come awake in an environment we can’t compare to any other. It appears as an absolute. What is, is, etc. We know the difference between living and dead, but both were always present, so the crucial difference does not exercise us. That sort of thing comes later, with development, and that experience—wondering about life, as life—isn’t everybody’s cup of tea. The What is, is remains an adequate explanation for lots and lots of people.

Some years back now I spent two years writing a book entitled What Does Life Want? I shopped it around, too, but had only a single positive reaction, that from a woman who thought it was great, fascinating, wonderful—but her firm couldn’t take it on, she said, and then came a litany of where that firm was now putting its emphasis. Those experienced in trying to publish books will know that this response was way, way beyond what you can expect in a rejection. I’d reached one reader—not the public. That book had had its origins in the question that arises later, after many years of life, if your curiosity is still alive and standard answers to the question, provided by various traditions, do not satisfy.

Life is as radical a phenomenon as self-awareness—and of course I don’t merely mean human life, I mean the life phenomenon. In its accessible, physical form, it is a chemical mechanism. In its behavior it is something one cannot find anywhere in the inorganic realm. It is end-seeking. It preserves, with enormous tenacity, complex forms generation after generation. But in every individual instance, it comes to an end. Yet it is, and always and only is, individual, whether that entity is a bacterium, a grass plant, or an elephant. This self-perpetuating something exists, so far as our telescopes can tell us, only in one place. Peopling the galaxies with countless life-supporting planets is a projection based on the notion that life is entirely material and arises spontaneously from chemicals “when the conditions are favorable”; thus it is a theory, not an incontrovertible fact multiply demonstrated in laboratories busy nurturing brand new man-made species. The presence of life, therefore, in an enormous wasteland of matter, is a question well worth exploration. A long but useful word is incommensurability. It applies to life when viewed against the backdrop of billions of galaxies each holding billions of suns, some few of which, by statistical extrapolation of the modern mind, will have planets situated just right and with the appropriate chemical composition, atmosphere, plentitude of water, etc., etc. to produce life spontaneously. Life as a whole for one, individual self-aware selves for another, are incommensurable to the inorganic order that seems to dominate the universe.

In making sense of all of this, living on a planet covered with life—but challenged by absence of really good telescopes on the one hand and electron microscopes on the other—the ancients took the weird single sample to be representative of the all. They assumed a chain of existence from matter to plants, to animals, to humans—and extended it upward to living orbs, angels, and God. They hadn’t as yet developed a plethora of machines as intricate as ours and fueled by the residues of life, which is what oil and coal are, or studied bodies and discovered that they’re machines. Nonetheless, minds more intuitive than intellectual and therefore less inclined to engage in intellectual system-building, discerned, already in ancient times, that something wasn’t entirely right in all of this, that something didn’t fit. Hence arose the fascinating religious projections suggesting that What is, is is just illusion, or that the world is the creation of an inferior demiurge, or that a race once living in an exalted paradise was forced from the garden by an angel with a flaming sword and, in consequence, fell, as it were, into another world.

Or into a kind of darkness, a dimension so low that the spirits, as they fell, saw nothing any more, were deprived of virtually all nourishing grace, and, in the great darkness, desperately started exploring that realm and adapting to it. Some glimmers must have been present even in those deepest depth because the ancestors of what we now call life began to notice patterns in the coarse energies they saw down there and nudged an electron here, one over there, to make a new combination. And thus began what I call chemical civilization. A long time ago.

Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Anne Boleyn

I woke up this morning with a dream. It concerned the deadlines of a book the author or translator of which was a certain clever but unreliable figure called Buleyn. Book deadlines used to be a major part of my life and still occasionally if only distantly worry me. In this dream someone asks me to call Buleyn to put the pressure on. I don’t approve of this request; I suspect that bugging our author will have precisely the wrong effect. So I refuse. But in the dream the name then catches my attention. I don’t know why, but (still in the dream) it fascinates me. I repeat it to myself, with emphasis: BULL-EYN, BULL-EYN. And doing so I visualize the name in letters. Such mental efforts, needless to say, invariably wake me up—and did so this morning. But the sound remained on my mind; the letters were there too. Within a minute an  association surfaced. Anne Boleyn. This made me look up that lady’s history after my breakfast.

Morning dreams, as I call those that wake me—and the sun’s already up—usually deal with mundane matters, looking ahead. At present a book is just some slogging steps from publication in our realm, and the dream refers to an already resolved problem with one lady author. What didn’t fit here was that name.

The thought then occurred. If this was a precognitive dream—in which, alongside morning thoughts I also saw the immediate future, thus reading about Anne Boleyn—it was a very circular dream. I’d never have looked up the name had not the dream brought her to mind. But what then comes to mind is that, most likely, we might be in a detached dimension in our dreaming where Time has a character quite different from that which we experience in waking consciousness. Along with processing recent memories, I was also seeing something that was still ahead, the associations of past and future fusing. Therefore a future action produced its own cause. The proof of that is found in the dream itself where my peculiar fascination with that name resulted in my repeating it, trying to spell it. Which is, truth to tell, always an issue, for me, with that name. It is pronounced Boleen, with emphasis on the “e” sound. I prefer Bolayn, which might be spelled Bollein, as indeed that name was sometimes spelled, e.g. in the illustration of the Queen by Holbein.

Can the future act upon the past? I think it can. We are able, occasionally, to see events in this dimension from another more generous perspective. And then, as it were, one thing leads to another.

Sunday, May 6, 2012

More Notes on Rebirth

In pondering the notion of reincarnation, certain questions arise. The evidence available (and it is strong) suggests that people are born again; but the number of such cases is relatively small. If it were universal, we’d have much larger numbers who remember, not just a few. Therefore it may well be that some people are reborn after death, but not all. The generalization from a small sampling to all of humanity is not based on evidence but on philosophical projections trying to explain the few cases that seemingly always arise—and not just in regions where reincarnation is generally accepted.

In the West the general belief is that souls are created by God at or around a baby’s conception. In Catholicism reincarnation was anathamized by the Second Council of Constantinople (533), which declared both that the “fabulous pre-existence of souls” as well as “the monstrous restoration which follows from it” were wrong. In the East (Hinduism, Buddhism) the pre-existence is assumed—and souls are assumed to be, as it were, sparks of the Ultimate itself, entangled in the material realm by their own illusions and held here until, overcoming them, they rejoin the Ultimate.

The belief held in the East, however, was also articulated by Origen (185-254), an early theologian of the Church in his book, Peri Archon (I’m cribbing from the Catholic Encyclopedia here). He also held that souls pre-exist their incarnation, having been created outside of time; their presence in time, thus in bodies, is the consequence of their own willful behavior. To quote the Encyclopedia: “Origen’s theory excludes both eternal punishment and eternal bliss; for the soul which has been restored at last to union with God will again infallibly decline from its high state through satiety of the good, and be again relegated to material existence; and so on through endless cycles of apostasy, banishment, and return.”  If Origen used those words literally, he was surely mistaken about satiety, but never mind…

In any case, fascinating. Origen ultimately derives this cycling from the operations of free will—which is at least a coherent sort of doctrine. It assumes that each of us, individually, caused our own fall rather than, as it were, getting our original sin by mere genetic inheritance. The alternative, that of being created in a fallen state, at birth, is, for me, incoherent. In the latter instance all we must try to explain is why we don’t remember the initial act that sent us to a realm where, every morning, we have to put on socks.

Just a handful of those who remember having lived one life before also remember the intermediate state between lives in another and always rather magical realm. And some very few among them also recall having been urged by one or several angels to come back to earth again. Why? Because, evidently, they needed to do so to develop further. Those are interesting cases. In most others, it just happens.

So what does all this suggest? Is the model developmental? If so, the engineering of such intricate machines as bodies would not have been done by the fallen creatures themselves but would be part of the divine plan (which, of course, is the orthodox teaching, but I find it hard to believe); this is a big subject; I will have to enlarge on it later. Something more complex is going on here. I suspect, however, that I’ll have to wait until my own border crossing before the structure that brings us here and receives us back over there—and what’s really behind it—becomes clearer. I’ll put this in that notebook I’ll take with me when I die.

Tuesday, May 1, 2012

Almeder on Stevenson



I read an article today by Robert F. Almeder, retired professor of philosophy at Georgia State University, in the Journal of Scientific Exploration titled “A Critique of Arguments Offered Against Reincarnation” (link). In the article Almeder makes the point that strong cases that provide empirical evidence for reincarnation—which the work of Ian Stevenson does—that evidence per se falsifies the modern theory that minds are the product of the brain, thus shattering the materialistic stance on human experience.

I got to thinking about that. What other empirical evidence do we have that “mind” or “soul” or “personality” are radically different from bodies and their functions? Near Death Experience reports fail on that score because, while technically the person undergoing an NDE may be dead (“clinical death”), he or she comes back to life to render an account, hence that “death” was not really final. Reincarnation cases are very different. Those who remember a prior life most definitely died but retain memories of another life in a current and new body. My conclusion, in effect, is that reincarnation cases may be the only evidence for the agency’s survival of death, evidence of the kind that may be called empirical, thus discoverable multiple times by different researchers, as has indeed been the case.

My own views on this subject are scattered throughout this blog and may be gathered by clicking on Reincarnation under Categories to the left. Almeder’s article requires some time and attention. A summary of his views is presented in the YouTube I show at the beginning of this post.

Sunday, April 29, 2012

Three Cultures

There are three forms of culture: worldly culture, the mere acquisition of information; religious culture, following rules; elite culture, self-development.
     [Ali Hujwiri, Revelation of the Veiled]

I’ve used this quote as an epigram before; I saw it many, many years ago, used for the same purpose in Idries Shah’s, The Sufis, and it made an impression on me even then—pre-Information Age and all of that—because it refers to information and, in part, inverts the order of layers within a culture. In the modern view “self actualization,” as the last level is called in modernese (by Abraham Maslow discussing hierarchies of needs), is till at the top, but religious culture is viewed as something we’ve progressed beyond to reach the current pinnacle of secular civilization.

Hujwiri, a Sufi teacher, lived a long time ago—990-1077—and clearly had a very sophisticated view of culture, as expressed when he described the basic level as engaged in seeking information. That’s all that’s really possible—at the worldly level. What comes above it transcends “the world” as we usually understand it.

Got to thinking about this today as I was pondering Yeat’s poem, The Second Coming, in which appear those famous words, “the center cannot hold.” Yeats (1865-1939) belongs to elite culture if anybody does; and beyond most poets he was interested in matters mystical. And he saw the problem, to be sure. Worldly culture, even when he wrote that poem, in 1920, was already overwhelming the second layer for many people: religious culture. Yeats saw that as a great disaster because he saw no hope. The Second Coming he darkly foresaw was that of something beastly:

A shape with lion body and the head of a man,
A gaze blank and pitiless as the sun,
Is moving its slow thighs, while all about it
Reel shadows of the indignant desert birds.

Well, perhaps he failed to look far enough ahead—or his mysticism wasn’t deep enough. What he describes slouching towards Bethlehem to be born was modernity itself, not that which will follow its falling apart.

All this then led to another thought. If we look at Hujwiri’s categories, what seems to be clear is that the bottom and the top layers are always present—unless some plague or atomic war sends us back to hunting and gathering again; even that would leave one in place. Organized societies are a kind of necessary foundation for anything higher—except the elite culture at the very top. The elite culture is also always there; it springs from individual endowments. On this view, anyway, the middle layer, religious culture, is the most important. It provides social cohesion and is the vehicle by which masses of people can raise themselves, with the help of teachings and obedience (a despised word in this day) to realize transcendence—which is Job 1 in Sufi thought.

Saturday, April 28, 2012

The Wider Feminine Dimension

If and when we marry, we gain a second mother. In secular language the added phrase, “in law,” signals that we live in an Age of the Contract in which the state, enforcing the secular nature of its culture, demands the right to permit us to marry. But in the greater realm, thinking now of Genesis (2:24), marriage makes man and woman “one flesh.” (I note here that that phrase is retained in all but two versions of every Bible I own; the Jerusalem Bible renders it as “one body,” which is equivalent; the Living Bible shifts the ground into the abstract and says “one person.”)  If we are one flesh, however, doesn’t the spouse’s mother also become our own?

This somewhat cumbersome beginning, however, is not really my subject. I’m just a tracing how I got to my theme. A post on Ghulf Genes and some commentary on it brought the Sibyls of old to the fore, again, and every time that happens, I always think of my second mother, as it were. Now this wondrous lady, long since departed, was as modern as any, a practicing dentist, married to an eminent economics consultant, an enterprising person who, in the chaos that followed World War II formed a business to make a living for her family. She came from the high middle class, with real wealth in her background. And yet… And yet she was also a strange sort of person with peculiar gifts, so much so that, ever since I got to know her—and the occasions were few because she lived in the then barricaded East Germany and we rarely saw her—I always thought of her as sibylline, oracular, chtonic, and original.

Now today my memories of Mom Elvira—and of the Sibyl of Cumae and her predecessors and her followers, of whom I view St. Hildegard of Bingen (the “Sibyl of the Rhine”) as one—reminded me of my (these days) entirely incorrect conviction that women and men are different. Not under “law,” mind you, not in the sphere of contracts. But in reality. And particularly in the religious realm, the feminine perception is altogether more encompassing, holistic—but largely influential above and below the huge but narrowly mechanical noise produced by the masculine approach—heavy on intellect, law, rules, dogmas, sin, trial-judgement-punishment-reward, heresies, fatwas, and all the bloody rest.

With the rise of the Age of Contract, the feminine dimension came under attack—so that the Reformation dethroned and banned the Virgin Mary—as also it got rid of images, colors, decorations in the churches and the temples—a basic expression of the feminine soul. It was Robert Graves, I think, who said that first the success, and then the endurance, of Catholicism had everything to do with Mary’s superintending presence over the Church. Women hold things together, men are ever at war—so that the Reformation produced an endless scattering differentiation until the Whole was thus no more. (Yes. The root of that word, catholic, is the Greek kata, meaning “about,” and holos, meaning whole. It is. It is about the Whole.) Yet, of course, the feminine is always inclusive. And in that process of inclusion, conflicting details need to be harmonized; and where the conflicts are particularly gritty, they must be transcended by love—even if that demands that intellectual precision is sacrificed to the greater cause of Unity.

Now the religious urge in us is really, fundamentally, about love. And when religion comes to mean conflict, be sure that the masculine drive to power has hi-jacked something and, the moment that drive succeeded, the holy changed into something else.

Among the males the poets know this. They have been blessed with souls in which something of the nature of their mothers has managed to rise enough to celebrate the Goddess.

Sunday, April 22, 2012

Blank Simian Rote

A reviewer in the London Review of Books, Glen Newey, wrote in the March 2012 issue words I found refreshingly on point—although somewhat removed from the book he was reviewing, one dealing with human failures in the realm of statistical inference. Here is the passage that caught my eye:
Human existence is an acquired taste, and many of us get through it with the aid of what Vladimir in Waiting for Godot calls the “great deadener”. Blank simian rote—the round of feeding, grooming, ablution, slack-jawed vacancy—serves to block out tracts of time that might otherwise get colonized by anxious thought.
The first sentence is a bull’s eye, in a way. I don’t know Mr. Newey’s own stance on cosmology, but in mine that sentence is descriptive—because I don’t think that we belong here. And “blank simian rote” will bounce around in my own slack-jawed vacancy for a bit yet, bringing a little smile—as it has now for a few days since reading the phrase. I have this maddening habit of sometimes becoming aware of people’s ears when I watch TV; the situation is always one of intellectual exchange, interviews, or speakers behind a podium, usually on C-Span. The content is abstract, in other words, but I’m suddenly fixated on the ears. And yes, I am. I’m seeing a simian holding forth learnedly on some global subject of complexity. We find ourselves in bodies, sort of wake up in them. And when I watch little babies, it’s quite apparent that they’re surprised, baffled, and exploring what this thing is, meaning their little hands and little legs and toes. And the acquisition of the habit happens quite naturally.

Then it goes on for a while—make that decades—before a kind of reversal of that process begins. At minimum you notice that people have ears—and in the ultra-sophisticated world of abstraction and high technology, with ritual garments and blow-dried hair or sculpted coiffeurs more or less sublimating the underlying ape, only the ears remain as drastic reminders of what we are beneath the highfaluting reasoning that vibrates the air that the ears manage to detect and then to signal inward by incredibly sophisticated bio-technology until neuron servers make it audible to the mind—a mind that acquired a taste, as it were, for human existence—and then with age, is beginning to lose the habit. Because “seeing ears” is just the beginning.

Another of my symptoms, anyway, showing that the process is reversible, is when I hear of 70 or 80 or 90 year-olds praised to the heavens for their heroic fight, usually against cancer. And I wonder why it is so heroic to keep holding on, to the bitter end, when the ape just wants to lie down and die. My reviewer tells me why; they resisted being colonized by anxious thought. In them, evidently, the blank simian rote is still all right. The heroes are still hanging on; evidently they didn’t spend much time in thought and wonder, wonder about who they really are and what they’re really doing here. If they had they wouldn’t fight so hard when the end comes knocking on the door. They would’ve been waiting for Godot, not fearing the encounter.

A lifetime of thought, however, and not always anxious thought, either, produces insights that really help as the trip to the Garden of Simia begins to draw to its close. One can have a fair amount of fun, too—not least studying people’s ears. And, by the way, you can’t get away from them. Your own are there in the mirror to tell you that you too have a pair. Then, if you’re a man, you envy women who can hide them so well. Just checking on the spelling of the word “coiffeur” just now, I am looking on my screen, to the right, at a page featuring what is called Coiffeur D’Elegance. It shows five lovely ladies’ hairdos—and not an ear in sight.

Tuesday, April 17, 2012

Fallen Orchid

This orchid has a long and, for an orchid anyway, dramatic history. It was first planted in some kind of commercial garden and sold along with probably about eighty others to the operators of an office building in Southfield, MI called the Onyx Building. We had our offices there back then. It reached our own suite as a gift from the landlord—and every other office got one too. The orchid stayed in that air-conditioned space, with glorious views of a vast parking lot, until I drove it right across the Detroit Metroplex to the east side, and it has since then occupied this space in Brigitte’s bedroom window, growing from a quite small plant into this gorgeous thing. How old is it? It’s nine years old. I took this picture just the other day.

Faithful orchid—living against the odds. Orchids are air plants. They grow attached to trees or other sturdy growths in the tropics, and use these as a place to hold themselves. Their seeds are so tiny they easily float in the air; currents carry them high into the trees where they settle and then, growing, attach through so-called air roots. Our brave orchid is out of place. No stout tree to give it shelter. A stiff rod serves it, poorly, for support, with help from a bit of twine. It has some plastic butterflies for company. In place of a desired “jungle out there” it can only sense vast masses of brick.

It occurred to me, looking at this picture, that our orchid symbolizes the human condition too. We too are out of place—and live an odd adventure in a fallen dimension. The difference is that the orchid, being more innocent or stalwart than we are, takes it all in stride and simply thrives and blooms.

Saturday, April 14, 2012

Meaningful Coincidence

Just yesterday I was reading in a book authored by the Portuguese philosopher José Antonio Antón-Pacheco some reflections on Miguel de Unamuno’s The Tragic Sense of Life. That reading immediately predisposed me to like Unamuno’s general view of reality. This morning I come across one of Unamuno’s poems on Siris (link) titled “The immortality of the crab.” And in following that up, I encountered  another take on that subject written by Mexico’s leading poet, José Emilio Pacheco. The two Pachecos are not, as best I can discover, related in any way—but that simply adds to the coincidence.

Not alone in the world, not among the poets, anyway—or poet-philosophers—in feeling kinship with the grass and with the crab, expecting to encounter them even on the other side...of the Borderzone.